界面新闻记者 |
界面新闻编辑 | 黄月
dangyiweimamajuedingzhuixing,huifashengshenme?2012nianzhi2014nian,yanyuanbennidikete·kangbobaqitongguojuji《shentanxialuoke》zouhong,“kangbobaqire”chengweixijuanquanqiudewenhuaxianxiang。duiaodaliyazuojiatabise·kawan(tabitha carvan)laishuo,neiyeshitadelianggehaizichushengdenianfen,danshiyubennixiangyoudeguanzhubutong,tabiseganshoudaodeshiyizhongwuzhijingdetingzhi,tabuzaixiezuo,beihuaiyunheburuchixuzhaqu。raner,zheiyiqiezaitamishangbennidiketehoufashenglegaibian,yechengweiletaxiexia《woyaokuaile!dangmamamenkaishizhuixing》deqiji。
zheibenshukansishiyiweimamamishangbennidezhuixingzhilu,shijishangjiangdeshinvxingruheduohuizhuixing、dutongrenxiaoshuo/yanqingxiaoshuo、xiailiuxingwenhuadeng“neijiudekuaile”(guilty pleasure)dequanli。zaiyu“kangbobiao”(bennidefensinicheng)、tongrenxiaoshuozuozheshenrujiaotanhou,kawantichulezhuduoshenjudangxiaxingdeyiti:weihenvxinghuizaidangshangmuqinhouxianruduimingrendemilian?weihenvxingzongweizijidechimizize,wufaxiangnanrenneiyangjinxingwanshua?tajingyadifaxian,chengweimuqinrutongjinrudierciqingchunqi,erzheishiyinwei,nvxinghuizaizheigegengkanzhonglixing、dulisikaodengjiazhideshehuixitongzhongbiandizijizhenzhengreaideshiwu,chizhiwei“heilishi”bingyunianshaodeziwojianxingjianyuan;nanxingzekeyizhuazhuzijideaihao,batabianchengzhongshengdejiqing,shenzhishiyifenshiye。
zaibenshuzhongwenbantuichuzhiji,jiemianwenhua(id:booksandfun)lianxianzhuanfangletabise·kawan,yiqiliaoleliaozhuixingmamadeshenghuoyijitaduimuzhi、nvxingdewanshuadengwentidekanfa,yijiwomenduishixiazuiliuxingdeouxiangtaile·siweifutegongtongdechimi。zaitakanlai,yiqieguigenjiedidouyuaiyouguan,eraiwuchadeng,zhengrutazaishuzhongsuoxie:“zhiyaowomenbeidadongle,dadongwomendejiujingshishenmehaizhongyaoma?”
01 初为人母与青春期相似,都不太确定自己是谁
界面文化:是什么促使你写了这本书?在大多数人看来,追星是一件私人且无需多加解释的事情,你却产生了强大的动力并完成了这本书。
塔比瑟·卡万:qichu,wojiushixiangxiexiebennidikete·kangbobaqi,woyouxuduochuangzuolinggan,suoyikaishixiexiexiaoduanwen,tougaojiwangzhan。houlai,woxieleyipianguanyumuzhiyijiwoduibennidiketedeganqingdewenzhang,zheipianwenzhangbeiyijiameiguoyuerwangzhanfabiao,fanxiangfeichangrelie,henduorenxiexingaosuwotamenyouguoxiangsijingli。zheirangwoyishidao,woyiweineixiefeichangsirenheteshudejingli,shijishiyigerenmenpingshibuhuitaolundezhongyaoxianxiang,zheishiwoxiangnuliqujieshita。
界面文化:《神探夏洛克》播出时的热潮至今还历历在目,本尼迪克特·康伯巴奇这个痴迷对象也很有意思,他有点“怪”,极具魅力却又不是传统意义上的魅力男性,比如他谦逊并尊重女性——你还很喜欢的哈里·斯泰尔斯(Harry Styles)也是同样的人。他的魅力到底是什么?这种痴迷偏好的变化是不是也说明了女性意识的变迁?
塔比瑟·卡万:wojuedebennidiketedetedianshi,tabushichuantongyiyishangdeshuaige,zheiyidianrangtagengyoumeilile,ruguoninengkandaotademeilisuozai,ta(zainiyanzhong)jiuhuibiandegengjingzhihetebie。tashiyigemingan、xinsizhenmideren,shanliangyoucongming,suoyouzheixiedouyutadewaibiaoxingchenglehudong,zheilingtachengweileyigefeichanglitideouxiang。zhiyunvxingyishidebianhua,kenengyouba,danyiqianyeyoudawei·baoyizheiyangdeouxiang。worenweiouxiangxuyaoshiyigefengfu、kegongchongfentansuodeduixiang,jinjinshizhangdemeihaibugou,womenxuyaoyouqudejingli、chusederenge,birubennidemeilihendayibufenlaiziyuxialuoke·fuermosi,tafeichangnanxiangchu,danshibennizheigeyanyuanqueheaikeqin、binbinyouli,zheizhijiandezhangliweifensidehuanxiangzhurulexuduohuoli。
halishilingyigezheiyangdelizi,tayouxiangsideminganhenvxingtezhi,tayeduichuanzhenvzhuangsihaobugandaoganga。youyisideshi,nvxingtongchangbeirenweixihuanyanggangdenanren,danshihalizhengmingle,yigenengyunvxingqizhihexiegongchudenanrenshihenyouxiyinlide。
buguowobixushuo,shuyubennidiketedeshidaiyijingguoqule,tarengranshiyigezhidezunjingdeyanyuan,danbuzaishitebieshouhuanyingdeouxiangle。wodaobuhuitebienanguo,tajiehunchengjiahouxiangyaobaohuzijidesishenghuo,zheiyangyehenhao,tayijingshanyaoguole,xianzaigailundaoxiayigele。
界面文化:你是在母亲这个身份的压抑和迷失下开始痴迷于本尼迪克特的。在你看来,痴迷为何会在这时发生?青春期和成为母亲后的“痴迷”又有怎样的不同?我记得你曾在《卫报》的文章中写过:“中年是新的青春期,曾经的轻微羞愧记忆,现在变成了非常令人担忧的生活现实。”
塔比瑟·卡万:wozongshimangyuzhaoguhaizi,meiyouzijideshijian,haoxiangwanquanshiquleziwo,bianchengleyigezhihuiweinai、dasaoweishengdemiaoxiaozhiren。youxiedongxiposhiwobixuzhaodaoyigechukou,zaineigejiqiyouxiandeshijielibiaodaziji 。qijianwonengzuodejiushizaijiakandianshi,danshineiyezugoule,zuyichengweiyizhongchudongneixindeciji,huanxingneixiewufazaiqitadifangbiaodadehuohua。wohenxihuandaihaizi,yexihuanzuomuqin,danzheizhishiwoshenghuodeyigefangmian。jiuzaiwoxuyaoyigechukoulaibiaodashenfendeqitamianxiangshi,ta(bennidikete)chuxianle。
zheiheqingchunqihenxiangsi,neiyeshiyigenibutaiquedingzijishisheideshiqi,biaodaziwodefangshiyetongyangyouxian。worenwei,“muqin”zheiyishenfendaizoulewoziqingchunqiyilaixingchengdesuoyoufuzaxing,tasuoxiaolewosuoguanzhushiqingdefanwei,rangwohuidaoqingshaonianshiqineigebenzhendeziji。dangran,zuoweimuqinheqingshaoniandezhuixingtiyanshibutongde,bijingshenchubutongdeshenghuohehuanjing,danshiduiwolaishuo,neixindeganjueshiyimoyiyangde——wanquanchenjinzaimilianyuxiyuezhizhong,bingshoudaojidaguwu。
zheiyeshiweishenmewohuijuedeganga,yinweiwoweiyishuxizheizhongganjuedeshiqijiushiqingshaonian,erxianzaiwoshiyimingmuqin,zheirangwodanxinzijideqingganzaixianghoudaotui。danshijishang,zhishizheizhongganjuezaiqingshaonianzhihouxiaoshi,xianzaizhongxinhuilaileeryi。
02 整个系统是为了保护男人的闲暇和快乐
界面文化:你在书中写到了其他“康伯婊”妈妈们,她们也经历着同样的尴尬感受,比如匿名参加本尼的网络论坛,不倾向于公之于众。为什么会这样?在澳大利亚,追星妈妈们又会遭受怎样的误解和偏见?
塔比瑟·卡万:dangnihaishiqingshaonianshi,xianranyongyougengduodeziyoushijianhegengshaodezeren,suoyichimiyumingxingshimeiwentide。danshisuizhenianlingzengzhang,youqishiduiyunvxinglaishuo,suoyoudekongxianshijiandouhuizhixiangzhaoguzeren:zhaoguzijidewaibiao、zhaogufumu、haizihegongzuo,genbenmeishijianjizijizhaodianlezi。ruguonixiangweizijitengchushijian,neikejiushiyijiandashile——nibixucongjiatingzhongchouchushijian,ranhourenmenhuishuonimeiyouhaohaoliyongshijian,nibushigehaomuqin。
yinci,dangyimingmuqinxiangweizijizuodianshiqing,tajihubukenengbuweicigandaobaoqian。danwentishi,nanrenyougengduodexianxiashijian,erqiemeitiandouyou,dangtamenbashijianhuazaizijishenshangshi,neijiubusuan“zhanyongjiatingshijian”。aodaliyayixiangzuixinyanjiubiaoming,congshiquanzhigongzuodenanxinggengqingxiangyuduanlianshenti,tamenxiwangzaiyitianzhongzuogengduoyundong,neimefangfajiushixiangqizi“jieshijian”。yushi,nanrenhuazaiyundongshangdeshijianyueduo,qizizuoqitashideshijianjiuyueshao。nanrendeshijianxiangdanhuangyiyangkeyibianhua,ernvxingdeshijianshigudingde。
界面文化:令人印象深刻的是,正如你在书中描述的那样——你的丈夫已经比许多已婚男士做得要好了,而你在结婚前也以为自己可以选择夫妻共同育儿。
塔比瑟·卡万:danshizheibingbuxianshi。jinguanwodezhangfuhenzhichiwo,danwohaishihuibeizaijiaweihaizi、qingjiazheiyangdeshikunzhu,nizhuandeqianjiuhuibianshao——yinweigongzuobianshaole。zheiyangyilaizhangfudegongzuojiubiandegengyouyiyi,nidegongzuobiandeyuelaiyueshao……zheixiexiaoshijiaqilaixingchengexingxunhuan。bingqie,jishizhangfurenweizijizuodejiawuheqiziyiyangduo,qiziyeyaoweilejingyingshenghuozuogengduonaoligongzuo,zheixieshizhangfubuhuikaolvde。
worenwei,ruguomuqinmenxiangyaozhaohuikuaile,diyibujiushibuyaoqiangqiushijian——zheijihushibukenengde。nibixuzaizheilitengchuxiekongjian(zhilezhizijidedanao),yongyouyigefengfudeneixinshijie。yinweitarucifengfu,nicaihuigandaozijiyounenglicaiqujiexialaidecuoshi,birugengyouxiaodiliyongshijian,bingrangbierenmingbainixuyaogengduoshijian。
diyibujiushizhaodaoyigerangnijuedezijibi“muqin”zheigejiaosegengdadedongxi。nataile·siweifutejuli,tailedefensihuihuahenduoshijiansikaota,nikenengzuozaihuocheshang、zhizhididingzheqianfang,neixinquebolanzhuangkuo。zheigefangfaduimuqinlaishuoyezaihaobuguo,takeyiyibianpeihaizihuozuofanyibianzheiyangzuo。
界面文化:这本书的另一个重点是“内疚的快乐”(guilty pleasure)。如你所说:女性没有说出口的,恰恰是女性情感中最有价值的部分。你是怎样逐渐意识到自己无需为快乐感到内疚的?你如今又怎样看待这个说法本身?
塔比瑟·卡万:zheigezhuanbianguochengyuwozuoweimuqindeyishizhuanbianshitongyangde。muqinweizijizuoderenheshiqingdouhuilingtaneijiu,yinweineiyiweizhezhanyongjiatingshijian。jishishimanpaozheiyangduijiankangyouyidehuodong,yeshizailangfeishijian。buguanshixihuanbennidikete、shuainstagramhaishigenpengyouliaotian,tamendoushiyiyangde。
suoyi,nigenbenjiuyingbule,zhenggexitongdeshejijiushiweilebaohunanrendexianxiashijianhekuaile,bingrangnvxingchengdangengduozhaoguzeren,rangtamenbazhuyilijizhongzaibierenshenshangerbushiziji。shishishang,genbenmeiyouliyoushuozuqiubibennidikete·kangbobaqigengyoujiazhi——baituo,zuqiushixugouchulaideyouxi,ranhourenmenpaolaipaoqu。danshiwomenyijingjieshoulezheixiangyundong,renweitashishenghuodezhongyaozuchengbufen,daliangdezijinhexinwenguanzhutouruqizhong,renmencongweiweicigandaoxiuchiguo。
youmingnvxingjiwoxieguoyifengxin,tashitaile·siweifutedefensi,zaiyijiazhiyuandabufenshinanxingdegongchenggongsigongzuo。liangnianqian,tailedezhuanji《wuye》(midnights)faxingshi,tashuo“woxuyaoqingyitianjia,yinweiwoxianghuayitianshijiantingzheizhangzhuanji”,bangongshidemeigerendouzaiquxiaota,shuotaxianggexiaonvhai,wentadezhentoushangbuhuixiuzhedujiaoshouba?danshitazhichu,zaibangqiusaiji,zheixienanxinghuihuanxiangzhezheigeweizheqiupaodeyouxi,jiazhuangneizhiqiuduizhendecunzai,tamenyehuiqingjiakanbangqiu,haoxiangmeishenmebibangqiugeng“chengshu”le。
界面文化:泰勒正是以前会被轻视的那类歌手,因为她唱的都是“肤浅”的感情生活,但是这种观点如今已经被扭转了。
塔比瑟·卡万:是的,我在书中引用了那名心理学家卡罗尔·吉利根的观点(注:女性主义心理学家,她提出了一种不同于男性视角的伦理观,不是强调独立与分离,而是互相联系和关心他人,也包括关心过往的自己而不至于与真实的自己失去联系)。jibainianlai,nanrenyizhizaishuokeguan、quanwei、qiangda、dulicaishihaode,danneizhishitamendexiangfa。shuyibaiwanjidenvhaihefunvzhengzaibiaoming,womendetixi——zhenshi、cuiruo、chengshi、kuaile、rezhongyutanlunqinggan——tongyangjiazhiliancheng,erzheijiushitailesuozhanshideyiqie。
03 说粉丝行为既危险又值得担忧,令我感到沮丧
界面文化:你在书中提到了女儿对于粉色和公主装扮的喜爱,而你从最开始的拒斥、认为这不够“女性主义”,转而意识到这种想法也是在否定女性的声音,可以讲讲心路历程的转变吗?我看到,你前阵子还陪女儿去了时代巡演的现场。
塔比瑟·卡万:meicuo,woyiweiwoshuo“nibuyongfeidexihuannvhaiziqidedongxi,nikeyixihuanrenhedongxi”jiushizaibangzhutuozhantadeshijie。ketazhishigehaizi,tajieshoudexinxiqishishi——kanlailingyixiedongxigengyoujiazhi,woxihuanzheixiezhishiyinweitamenbeituixiaojilewo。woyishidao,woxuyaogulitazoutadelu,jiuxiangguliwoerziyiyang,ertaxihuandeshiqichehehuoche。zheifanguolaiyingxianglewo,zuoweiyimingnvxingzhuyizhe,wocengjingduihuazhuanggandaohenmaodun,zhiyiwoshifoushibeipode,danshishishang,tukouhongchumendeganjuefeichanghao,woturanjiushiranle,buxiangzaiqushenchazijidexingwei。
dainverqushidaixunyanshiworenshengzhongzuibangdejinglizhiyi,zaixianchangkeyikandaosuoyounianlingduandenvxing,youxiangtazheimexiaodenvhai,yeyouersanshisuihuosishiduodenvxing,haiyoumamamen。dajiajinqingwanlejianjiao,chuanzijixiangchuandeyifu,zheijiushitaxuyaodebangyang。wodechengzhangjinglilejudadebianhuaheduanlie,danshitabubizaijinglizheixie,tabubizaishuo:wozhangdale,meifazaiquyanchanghuile。ruguotazairenshengdemeigejieduandouxiangzheiyangzuo,neizheijianshijiubuxuyaojieshu。
当泰勒的新专辑《折磨诗人部》(The Tortured Poets Department)发行时,我觉得我女儿是不会理解这些歌曲的想法的,毕竟很多东西她还不懂,但是她绝对能体会到其中的感情。比如当她跟唱《Who's Afraid of Little Old Me》(注:一首曲风暗黑怪诞/表达愤怒情绪的戏剧性歌曲),tawanquanlejiezheishougechuandachudeliliang。zheidequehenshenqi,womendeshenghuojinglibutong,queyouzhexiangtongdejingyan。
泰勒也是这样拥抱她所有的专辑,以及专辑所代表的时代的,她如今35岁,还在台上唱着15岁创作的歌曲,歌曲的意涵仍然有效,她也仍充满热情。我也是如此,可以随时进入所有这些“时代”,我想现阶段我应该正处于泰勒意义上的“大名誉时代”(Reputation Era)(注:简单来说,这是一个与女性复仇和反叛相关的时代)。
guigenjiedi,yiqiedouyuaiyouguan,wulunshidangwodenverkanxiangtaishangdetaile,haishidangwokanxiangshenbiandenver——tamenshitongyizhongqinggan,jiuxiangnanshengduizuqiudeaiyiyang,womenzhixuyaodiaozheng“ai”dedingyiheshiyongfanwei。zheizhongqingganshijijide,suoyimeicibierenshuofensixingweijiweixianyouzhidedanyou,doulingwogandaojusang。
界面文化:你觉得自己的想法转变在多大程度上受到时代思潮变化的影响?在我的印象中,集体性承认“肤浅的”女性经验是在近两年才开始的(伴随着电影《芭比》爆火等文化现象),在“本尼迪克特热”的那几年还不完全是这样。
塔比瑟·卡万:zheibenshu2022nianzaiaodaliyachuban,jishizaiwoxieshudeqijian,shiqingyezaifashengbianhua。shishishang,shidaixunyancong2023nianchuntiankaibandaoxianzai,suizheyuelaiyueduoderenjiarukuanghuan,zheichangkuanghuanyouchixulezheimejiu,gongzhongduitaile、duinvxingwanledekanfayeyizhizaifashenggaibian。suoyiwohenqingchu,zheibenshudeduzhebuwanquanshinianqingren,yinweitamenyijingbuzaiweimimeideshenfengandaoxiuchi。woshiweixiangwozheiyangderenxiezheibenshude,tamenchengzhangyulingyigeniandai,guannianhaibijiaoluohou,ruguobujinkuaizhuanbianzijideguannian,henyoukenenghuiyingxiangwomendenvermendechengzhang。
wozaidianyingyuankanle《babi》,dangshiyanmamadeneiweiyanyuanyameilika·feileilafabiaoneiduandubaishi,suoyouguanzhongdouzaiguzhang。erjiuzai《babi》shangyingqijian,nvzushijiebeizhenghaozaiaodaliyajuban,neiyeshiyigezhongyaodeshike,womenkandaohenbangdenvhaizaicongshizheixiangyundong。suoyi,zheibenshunengzaizheishichuban,woyegandaohenxingyun,yinweiguobulejinianshulideguandianjiuhuibiandewuliaoerchenjiule。
界面文化:你接触过很多比你年长的本尼迪克特粉丝,她们的年龄远超过社会认知中会爱上名人的年龄。为什么会这样?在中国,年长女性的情感需求也是一个备受忽视的话题,许多人会对短视频里被捏造的明星产生依恋而受到诈骗。你接触的女性们又处于怎样的状态?
塔比瑟·卡万:wojingchangshoudaoduzhelaixin,youxierenyijing75huo80suile,dantamenrengranjuedeziji(zhuixingshi)deganshouhenianqingshiyiyang,zheijianshichengweitamenshenghuozhongdemaodian,rangtamendeyirenqingzhenzhengdezijishishei。
beizhapiandeyigeyuanyinkenengshilaonianrenquefanianqingrendewangluosuyang,danwoxiangshuodeshi,ruguoyimingnvxingdeqingganxuqiubushishenmebixubaochisimi、kechidedongxi,neitamenyexujiubutaikenengchengweipianzidemubiao,yinweitamenwuxuzaineilixunqiuqingganlianjie。suoyi,changshijiangzijideganshouhehuanxiangzhengchanghuafeichangzhongyao。tongshi,nianqingyidaiyekeyizengqiangshangyidaidenengli,henduonvxingxiexinjiwo,doushiyouyutamennverdeguli。
界面文化:如你在书中所说,男性往往在保护玩耍成为其生活的一部分方面做得更好。对于那些想要更好地玩耍的女性,你有什么建议吗?
塔比瑟·卡万:shouxian,buyaoweixihuandeshiqinggandaobuhaoyisi。tamenmingmingzhidaoshenmenengrangzijikuaile,quechuyuneijiuerburangzijixiangshouqizhong。qici,changshizaineixinshenchuxiangzhenzhengxiaidedongxikaolong,yongnidefangshiqusikaota。youshihou,jiandandiyongyouyigexihuanbangqiudenanrenneiyangdezixinyehenbucuo。
评论