上海夜店网

正在阅读:

nongcunfunvtudiquan,manzhangdekangzhengrengzaijixu

saoyisaoxiazaijiemianxinwenapp

农村妇女土地权,漫长的抗争仍在继续

“zuizhongyaodeshiyinggaijitamenzijixuanzedequanli。”

wen | meirirenwushe linsongguo

编辑 | 姚璐

yunying | xiaolu xiaoerlang

2024nian6yue28ri,jingguosancishenyi,《zhonghuarenmingongheguonongcunjitijingjizuzhifa》zuizhongtongguo,jiangyu2025nian5yue1rizhengshishengxiao。zheishiyibu“qianhuwanhuanshichulai”defalv,tagongbuneitian,zaiquanguohenduodifang,henduonvxingshenyeweimian,tamenzaixiangxiang,xinfajiangruhegaibianzijidemingyun。

guoquzheixienian,nongcunfunvdetudiquanyi,chengleyigezongyouzhengyiquechichiwufajiejuedewenti。nongcunzaifazhan,zuoweiyigejitijingjizuzhi,tahuiyudaochaiqian、fenhong……erzuoweicunzhuanglidenvxing,changchangyindalingweihun、jiehun、lihun、sangoudengyuanyinbeiduoquan。2023nian8yue,yiweizhejiangnvxingdeweibobeizhuanfaguo2.6wanci——tayinyuwaidinanxingjiehun,chengle“chujianv”,yizhangbobodejiehunzheng,tashiqule120100yuandetudizhengyongkuan。

zheibufalv,shilishishangdiyicidui“heweinongcunjitijingjizuzhichengyuan”zuochuguiding:“funvxiangyouyunanzipingdengdequanli,budeyifunvweihun、jiehun、lihun、sangou、huwunanxingdengweiyou,qinhaifunvzainongcunjitijingjizuzhizhongdegexiangquanyi。”tadechutai,huoxuhuigaibianmouxiexianshi,rangshiquanzhededaojiuji。

linlixiashibeijingqianqianlvsuofunvtudiquanyixiangmudefuzeren,guoqu20duonian,zaibeijingbeisihuanyijianjuminlougaizaoerchengdebangongshili,tahetongshimenjiedaoguochaoguo3000weinongcunnvxingdeqiuzhu,jinjisuonengweitamenbenzou,danzuihounengshengsudenvxing,buzuyicheng。

zheishiyitiaomanzhang、jiannandedaolu。meirirenwucengquwangzhejiangheguangdong,jiandaolejiwei“chujianv”。tamenyoudexiangdangnianqing,gangyinweijiehunershiquletudibuchangkuan,yanlihaiyoubuganhezhengzheng;youdebeijiarenhecunzhuang“quzhu”,modemeilexinqi,wojuzaihunandechuzufangli;haiyoudezhuzaicunzhuangbianyuan,dangwomenzouzaicunli,tahuisuoqibozisongzhejian,xiaoxinyiyidiliuzhebianer。danxiangtongdeshi,tamendoujianxin,zijibuyinggaiyinweixingbieershiquan。

ruhejiangzheixiebugan,zhuanhuaweigaibianxianshideliliang?zheixienian,linlixiahetadetongshimenzuoledaliangdegongzuo,shitujianliyitiaogoutongtujing。tamenweijicengnvxingweiquan,yetongguodaliangdexinxi、shuju、ziliaoheyantaohui,jinliyingxiangjuececeng。tamenzaicunzhuangtuiguangjuyoupingdengshijiaodecunguiminyue,yeshitutongguodifangfayuanhefulian,gaibianjubudexiaoqihou。

2023nianchu,《zhonghuarenmingongheguonongcunjitijingjizuzhifa(caoan)》gongkaixiangshehuizhengqiuyijian,linlixiayuqianqianlvsuodetongshimen,diyishijiantijiaolexiugaijianyi,youshangwanrenzhuanfa。

zhihouwomenyigongjianguolinlixiasanci,fangtanchaoguo10xiaoshi,womenliaoqizhei20niantajianguodeneixienvxing,tamenderouruanyujueqiang,weilezhengququanyi,tamenzuoguonaxienuli,yijiweiraonongcunfunvtudiquandefazhixijie。

meicijianmian,linlixiajirendeyinxiangdoushihengdingde:tashoushoude,bangzhemawei,zaiwendubugaodebangongshiliguozheyurongfu,shouwoyibeicha。wulunwomentandaodeneirongruhejingxindongpo,rangrenfennuhuotanxi,tazongshixiandepingjing、jianding,shaoyoujiliedeqingxubiaoda。huoxuzhengshizheiyangyizhonghengdingdejingshenliliang,cainengzhichiyigeren、yigezuzhi,zaizheiyangyijianshiqingshangjianchi20nianzhijiu。

yixiashilinlixiadejiangshu:

不婚也失权,结婚也失权,离婚也失权

woshisichuanren,zuizaoshizailaojiadeyisuozhongxuezuoshengwulaoshi。zongshikandaobugongpingdeshiqing,jiuxiwangnengzouchulai,nengjiandegengduo。1995nianwolaidaobeijingxueyingyu,yeshihenouran,1997nian,yiweilaoshituijianwodaoqianqianlvsuo(dangshijiaobeidafaxueyuanfunvfalvyanjiuyufuwuzhongxin)gongzuo。wojuedezheigegongzuomanyouyiside,yishikeyibangzhunvxing,ershikeyilejieshehui,jiuliuxialaile。

zuichuwoshicongxingzhenggongzuozuoqi,bingzaizhidulefalvdeyanjiusheng,zhihoukaishixiezhulvshicanyuanjianbanli。zaizheigeguochengzhong,nihuikandaoshidaiyitibuduanbianhua:congfunvzhuixintaochoudenglaodongquandewenti,daolihunhaizifuyang、caichanfengedenghunyinjiatingwenti,zaidaojiatingbaoli、zhichangxingsaorao,zuihou,wokaishifuzenongcunfunvtudiquanxiangmu。

dagaishi2005nianzuoyou,jiuzaizheigebangongshi,congnanninglailejishigeren,doushichujianv。dangshitamenzhuangkuanghenbuhao,meidifangzhu,nanfangbajiaoyebushihendama?tamenjiukandianmaozhu、shugan,zaishangmiangaishangbajiaoye,zhefengdangyu,yijiarenjiuzheimeshengcun。dangshijirendezhenhanshitingdade。

2005nianshiyigebijiaozhongyaodeshijianjiedian。dangshichengshihuajinchengjiakuai,fazhandezaodeguangdong、guangxizheixiediqu,chujianvdejiufenyijingyoule,neiludiquchengzhenhuajianshekaishi,yeyoulezhengdi、chaiqiananzhiwenti,womenjiukaishijiedaolaiziquanguogedideqiuzhudianhua。tamenyoudeshikandaolemeitibaodao,youdeshikoukouxiangchuan,jiuzheimezhaoguolaile。

“chujianv”quntiqishishihendade,yinweiweihun、jiehun、sangou、lihun、zaihunersangshilequanlidenvxing,doukeyibeichengweichujianv——xianshijiushizheimedingyide——nimeijiehun,danzhiyaojialiyouerzi,nizhongjiudoushiyaochujiade;jielehun,nijiushuyufujiale;nisangoule,tamenyejuede,nikendinghuizaihun;lihunleyeshiyiyang。zongdelaishuo,nvxinghuiyinweihunyinerliudong,tamendequanli,yeyinweizheizhongliudong,erdebudaobaozhang。

gezhongshiquandeqingkuang,womendouyudaoguo:

meijiehunjiushiquande——zaihunanxiangtan,yougecundecunguiminyuejiuguiding,“nianman28zhousuideweihunnvxing,budecanyurenhefenpei”。cunliyougejiating,you3genverhe1geerzi,dangshidanveryijiehun,hukouweiqianchu,jiehunhoujiushiqulefenpeiquan;linglianggenver,man28suizhihou,yebeiquxiaoledaiyu。lianggexiaonverbufuqi,quqisu,fayuanhaipantamenshengsule,rangcunlibazhengdibuchangkuanjitamen,qishimeirenyejiuyiliangqiankuaiqian,dancunlijiushibuji。

dangshiwohewodetongshiquledangdi,womenjiuxiangzhidao,weishenmebuzhixing?cunlidezhanghu,guixiangzhencaizhengsuoguanli,womenjiuqucha,cunlidaodiyoumeiyouqian,faxianhutoushangqueshimeiqian,danyougechujianvfaxian,ei,zenmewomencunzheigerenhutoushangyou300wan?shijishang,cunliguyibaqiannuodaolezheirendezhangshang。womenjiugenxiangzhentan,weishenmebunengqiangzhizhixingni,xiangzhenjiushuo,zhiqiancunjitideganbudaizhehenduonanxingcunminlaiguole,tamenshuo,xiangzhenyaoshiganjiqian,tamendaoshihoujiulaiweigongxiangzhenzhengfu。zhengfuyehaipa,chujianvbijingshishaoshu,erzheigecun,shijiqianrendeliyigongtongti。

下乡调研时,林丽霞访谈村书记。图 / 讲述者提供

jielehunjiushiquande——zaihubeitianmen,yougejiatingyoulianggehaizi,gegeshicunhuiji,meimeishigaoducanji,meimeizheizhongqingkuang,zaidangdizhaoduixianghennan,danzheidifangbijiaofuyu,jiuzhaoleyigepianyuannongcundexiaohuoziruzhui,hukouyeqianguolaile,haishenglelianggehaizi,meimeizijiyenenggan,shigecaifeng。houlaiyudaozhengdichaiqian,cunlijiuburentazheiyijia。

womendangshiyequle,xiangzhenganbujiushuo,“nikan,liantagegedoubutongyiji。”womenjiuwentagege,weishenmebutongyi?tagegeshuo,ruguojile,neiyihoudajiajiehunhoudoubuyuanyizoule,bunengyinweitayouteshuqingkuang,jiuewaizhaogu。tamenjiujuede,suoyoudenvxing,zhiyaojialiyouerzi,nijiehunzhihoudouyinggaizou,quanliqupojiaxiangyou。zheishitamengenshendigudeguannian。

haiyouzaihunnvxingdesuiqianzinvshiquande——guangxinanningdegenvshijiwomendadianhuaqiuzhu,shuotamamadaizhetahedidi,jiajilejifu,danshihoulaimuqinhejifudouqushile。jifuyizou,cunlijiuhenpaichitamen,bujitamencunmindaiyu,shuotamenbushizheigecundexuemai。jinguanzaifalvshang,jizinv、hefashouyangdezinv,heqinshengzinvdequanlishiyiyangde。dancunlibuguan,tamenhaishirenkexuemaiguanxi。

zhiqianzai《yixi》deyanjiangzhongwoshuoguo,“dangzheixieshiqutudidefunvzhanchulaiweiquanshi,tamenwangwanghuibianchengyigejiating、yigecunzhuangdediren”,zheishizhende。womenzhenzhengqudaocunli,qubanzheixieanzi,nijiuhuiganjuedao,zuliqueshihenda,shenzhihuiyudaocunminlaiweigong。

wojide2014nian,wohezhongyangdangxiaodelihuiyinglaoshi,quqinghaiyigecunzi,xiangxiediaojiejuechujianvdechaiqiananzhiwenti。quzhiqianjiuzhidao,kenenghennan,maoduntaishenle,dangdifayuanyebushoulichujianvdesuqiu。zheigecundenanxingcunmin,meirenanzhiyitaofang,fumuyeyouyitao,yijialianggeerzi,jiuyousantaofang,neifangziwomenkanle,queshihenhao。danshichujianvjiushenmedoumeiyou,tamenzhinengpaodaohenbianyuandechengjiao,zudeshi100kuaiqianyigeyuedepopingfang。

womendaocunli,xiangzhaocunganbuliaoyiliao。faxiantongwangcunliangweibangongshideloudao,youyidaodatiemen,genbenshangbuqu,renjiaxianwenniyoushenmeshi,zaijiushuo,renbuzai。zouzaicunli,renjiadoushiyongyiyangdeyanguanglaikanwomen,nideyizhe,nibeidebao,tamenjiuzhidaonishiwailaideren,buyuanyigennishuohua。

在青海省的村子里调研。图 / 讲述者提供

“分明是我自己的权利,为什么别人来表决?”

weishenmechujianvweiquanzheimenan,2004nianwomenkaishijieshoudaliangzheileianjian,henkuaijiufaxian,zheileianjiandouyouyigegongtongdekunjing——neijiushi,guanyuchengyuanshenfenwenti,meiyoufalvyiju。

fayuantongchanghuirenwei,chujianvdequanli,shouxianxuyaoquerentamenshinongcunjitijingjizuzhichengyuan,shichengyuan,cainengxiangshouchengyuandaiyu。danwoguodangshidefalv,bingmeiyou“nongcunjitijingjizuzhichengyuan”derendingbiaozhun。dangranyuanzexingguidingshiyoude,biru《funvquanyibaozhangfa》《nongcuntudichengbaofa》,douyouguanyunannvpingdengqiepingdengxiangyoutudiquanlideguiding,《minfa》lihaiyoupingdenggongpingdeyuanze,zheixiedoukeyiyong。

zhibuguohenduoshihou,fayuanjuede,jiranbiaozhunmeiyouwanquanmingque,neizheiyileianjian,tamenyaomebushouli,yaomeshoulilezaibohui。zuizhongdezouxiang,doushituijicunminzizhi。

wokanhenduozhuanjiaxuezhexiewenzhangdoushuo,zhongguohenda,nongcunhenfuza,guanyuchengyuanzigewenti,bushihezuoxiangxiguiding,yinggaijiaojicunminzizhiqujueding。danzhei20nian,womenjiechulezheimeduojutianli,wojuede,jinguanquanguohenda,nongcunhenfuza,dangenbenwentishiyiyangde——neijiushiduihunjianvxingdeqishihepaichi。danchunyikaocunminzizhidejicengminzhuxingshi,jiushixianshizhongbingbunengyouxiaojiejueqinhaifunvtudiquanyidewenti。

zaiyixiecunli,nongcunjititudiquequandeguiding,henduoshihoujiushicunganbuzijidingde,huozhezhaoyixiecunmindaibiao,kaigehuitaolunyixia:zheibiqianzenmefen?chujianvfenbufen?wangwangzheishihou,dajiadoujuede,chujianvdangranbufen,nifenle,wojiushaole。dajiashicunzailiyichongtude。zheixienvxingwangwangdoubuzhiqing,zhishizuihougongshichulai,caizhidaozijimeiyou。

dangnianzaihubeihonghuyougeanzi,womendelvshiqubangchujianv,cunlijiuqingleyiweifaxuejiaoshoulaidaili,neiweijiaoshouzaifatingshanggongranshuo,zhongguodehunjiazhidujiushicongfuju,“jiachuqudenver,pochuqudeshui”,tahaishuo,jinguanzijishijiaoshou,zainongcunhaiyoutadechengbaodi,ruguozijidejiemeigentazheng,tayebutongyiji。“chujianvjiuyinggaiqupojia,buyinggailiuxialaigenxiongdizhengcaichan。”

weilezheigeanzi,womenqingdonglehubeishengfuliandequanyibuzhang,xiwangfuliannengguanzhu、tuijin。dandangdideyizhitaiqiangdale,womendesuoyougongzuo,zuihoudechengxiaozhibuguoshi——rangzhushenfaguanduiwomenkeqileyidian,bingmeiyouyingxiangpanjuejieguo。zheikanqilaishiyigehenxiaodeguansi,shiminjiande、laobaixingdeliyijiufen,danshijishangshiyizhongquanlizhizheng,beihouqianfuzhefuquanzhidechuantongguannian。

lingwaiyigedianxingdeanzi,shizaineimengbayannaoershidewanfengcun。youyigewaijianvjiaoyangzhijun,1982niancunlifendi,dangshitameijiehun,fendaole2.2mudi,zhihoutajielehun、shenglenver,yijiasankoujiushenghuozaicunli,danshidaole1985nian,cunlituranjiubatahenverdetudishouhuiqule,shuoshigenjuxianlidewenjian,waijianvhezinvdetudiyilvyaoshouhui。hetayoutongyangzaoyude,haiyou68weichujianv。

tadangranjuedehenbugongping,1985nianjiukaishiweiquan,congcunweihui、fulian、xiangzhen、qulidaoshili,jiejuebule,tajiuqisu,yishen、ershen、zaishen,falvchengxuquanbuzouwanle,fayuanrangtazhaozhengfu,zhengfuyaoqiuxiangzhenzhengfuzuzhizhaokaicunmindaibiaodahuilaijueding。huikailehaojici,yizhitongbuguo——jinianqian,tadidihaidanglecunzhang,tamenyijiaguanxihenhao,yehentuanjie,didiyexiangjiejuetadewenti,dancunminbiaojuejiushitongbuguo,buyuanyijitamen。zheigeminzhuchengxushiwufapochude。

yangzhijundexinggehenshaojian,tameiduguoshenmeshu,dandaolitebieqingchu,tashuo,“womenzuoweinvren,bingbushitianshengliduan,yeyinggaibeigongpingduidai”。tahaishuo,“weishenmejiaotamenchujianv,quebujiaonanrenchujiahan?”zheitiaoluzouxialai,womenyoushihoudoumeixinxinle,danshitatebiezhizhe,juebufushu,wulunruhedouyaojianchi,henduoshihou,womenshishoudaotadeguwuhetuidongcaijixuxiaqude。

“zheifenmingshiwozijidequanli,weishenmeyaobierenlaibiaojue?”zheijuhuayangzhijunshuoguo,henduochujianvyeshuoguo。hubeihonghuneigecundechujianv,jiuzhijiewenguocunshuji。qishijiushizheigedaoli。

danzaixianshizhong,nihuikandaocunminzizhizhong,shenzhishizhuanjiaxuezhedejianyizhong,youhenduokansihelidetiaojian,shizeshizaixianzhichujianv,rangtamenshiquan。

biru“yitudizuoweijibenshenghuobaozhang”。henduonvxingbaisu,panjueshulidoushuo,tabuyitudizuoweijibenshenghuobaozhang,zaiwaimianzuoshengyi、dagong……danwentizaiyu,zenmedingyi“baozhang”,xiandairenkoudeyigezhongyaotezhengjiushiliudongxing,nvxingzaiwaimiandagongzhengqian,yanghuoziji,yidanmeinenglile,hainenghuidaotudishang,youkoufanchi,worenweizheijiujiaojibenshenghuobaozhang。tuiyibushuo,nanxingcunminyezaiwaimiandagong,danweishenmefenpeishi,tamendounengfendao?wohoulaiwenguoyiweisixiangbijiaoxianjindefaguan,tashuo,chulehuodeguojiadaiyu(jinrutizhi)deren,qitacunminbenzhishangdoushiyitudiweishengde。wozantongzheizhongshuofa,guojiabatudimianfeijinongmin,jiushiduisuoyounongmindejibenshenghuobaozhang。

zaibiru“zhangqijuzhushenghuozaicunli”。worenshiyiduishandonghezedemunv,weilemanzuzheigeyaoqiu,tamendoubuganlikainongcunqudagong,tamenjuede,wobulikai,doudebudaozheigequanli,neiwolikaile,gengdebudaole。tamenjiuzaidangdizuojiazheng、zuolinggong。dangshiwomenquheze,bangtamenkailejiaoshuifeihedianfeidezhengming,5nianyongle9000duokuaiqiandedianfei,zheikendingnengzhengmingtajiazaizheiershenghuo,danzaifatingshang,cunshujihaishishuo,jucunminfanying,tamenmeiyouzhuzaicunli。nizaiyoushenmezhengju,cunliburen,haihao,zuihoufayuanrenkele。

haiyou“shifoulvxingyiwu”。qishi,renheyizhongshenfenquan,doushixianxiangyouquanli,zailvxingxiangyingdeyiwu,erbushixiangfan。yixiechujianvjiugaosuwomen,cunliweilebimianjitamenquanli,huiburangtamenjinyiwu,birukaihuibutongzhita;jibiantatingshuoyaokaihui,yiqu,renjiajiushuosanhui;bujitaxuanjuquan,tayewufacanyuxuanju。zuihoucunlijiushuo,nimeiyoujinyiwu,suoyiyebunengxiangshouquanli。zongzhi,xianshizhonghuiyougezhongliyoulaixianzhitamen。

keshizheigeshiqingshuodaodi,feichangjiandan——nvxingchushengzaizheili,anzhao《minfadian》deguiding,jiehunhou,nannvshuangfangduijuzhudidouyouxuanzequan,nvxingkeyiliuzainiangjia,yekeyiqupojia,chengweinagejitidechengyuan,doushitadexuanze。henduocunmin,shenzhidifangzhengfuhejicengfayuan,douhuiyouyizhongchengjian,juedetamenliuzaijialishitancai,jiuyinweijiaxiangjingjifazhanshuipinghao。yaorangtamendouliuxialai,fuyucunrenkoubujiubaozhale?

danwomenzhidao,henduochujianvbingbushizheiyang,tamenhenduodoushichengjiaodenvxing,renshilewaidilaidexiaohuozi,jiehunyihou,jiuzaibendishenghuo,shenglehaiziyeliuzaibendi,gongzuoshenghuo、haizishangxuedouhenfangbian。erqietuiyibushuo,jiusuanshiweileliyi,yewukehoufei,sheibuzhuiqiuliyi?basuoyoujihuiheliyidoujinanxingdechuantongguannian,yinggaigaibianle。nikeyifangkaihuaibao,jienaqurudexifuheqitawailaideren,weishenmejiubunengrangnidenverzaizheilianjialuohu?

杨志军(左四)为女儿结婚在村里租的平房。图 / 讲述者提供

选正义,还是选漏洞

zheimeduonian,yaoshuoyoumeiyoupandehenhaodeanzi,dangranshiyoude。

2006nian,neimengguhuhehaoteshizhongyuanpanleyigeanzi——28gechujianv,hukoudouzaicunli,zhangfudoushishangmennvxu,yushangchaiqiananzhi,meijiayinggaifen1.5mutudi、yitao70duopingfangmidezhuzhailou、yitaolinjieshangpu。nixiangzheishiduodadeliyi。

dangshifayuanpantamenyingle,neigepanjueshuxiedehenhao,henzhongshifunvquanyi,shiyongdeshi《funvquanyibaozhangfa》《xiaochuduifunvyiqiexingshiqishigongyue》,haiyinyongle《minfa》deyuanzehejingshen,shibapingdengluozailezhishang。

(zheifenpanjueshuyuanwenzheiyangxiedao:woguoshangweizhidingquedinggaizigedebiaozhun,weijiejuejiufen,yingshiyong《minfatongze》degongpingyuanze、leituipanduandeminfalilun,ji28mingchujianvyuyijingqudejitishouyifenpeidecunminxiangbijiao,ruguoshenfenjiqitatiaojianxiangdeng,zeyeyingdangqudexiangtongdaiyu。benande28mingchujianvchuxingbiewai,qitatiaojianyunanxingxiangdeng,yeyingdangxiangyoutongdengdequanli。)

zheijiushifayuanyinggaiyoudeyizhongzitai:dangyoujutifalvzuoweiyijushi,jiuyijujutidefalv;dangmeiyoujutidefalvyiju,nijiuyinggaigenjufalvdeyuanzehejingshen(laipanan)。

danzhihou,womennazhezheifenpanjueshu,quweiyangzhijundeanjianzhengqushi,yiweifaguanjiushuo,hushizheigeanzijuewujinyou。shenmeyisini?zheigeanjian,qishiyishenyebaisule,baisuhou,28mingchujianvyongshengmingkangzheng,suoyiershencaishengsu。suoyiwoshuo,nvxingdequanlizhenshikangzhengdelaide,yinweizhangqishouyapo,nixiangzhanqilai,zulihenda,zhendeshizaiyongshengmingkangzheng。

suoyishuotongyangdeanzi,weishenmeyoudedifangzhichi,youdedifangbuzhichi,jiushiyinweidangshifalvbuwanshan,youloudong。nixiangzhichichujianv,nengzhaodaoyiju,nibuxiangzhichichujianv,yenengzhaodaoyiju。jiukannizenmexuan,yaobuyaozhuanjianyouloudongdedifangzou。

zheixienian,quanguoyouyixiedifangzuodeyebucuo,zhengzhihuanjinghao,minfengyebucuo,fayuanyebijiaogongping,zheiyangdedifang,chujianvdejiufenxiangduijiushao。

birusichuan,2015nian,sichuanshengnongyetingjiuchutaileyigebiaozhun——nongcunjitijingjizuzhichengyuanquanyijiufen,yihujiweizhuyaobiaozhun,nichushengzaizheigedifang,hukouyezai,jiukeyixiangyouchengyuanquanyi,yinchusheng、jiaqu、shouyang、shenqingjiarudengqingkuang,fuhebiaozhundedoukeyixiangyouquanli。zheigeguidingbijiaoheli,yefuhenongcunshiji,xiangduigongping。zheigeguidingchutaizhihou,womenjiuhenshaojiedaosichuandeqiuzhu。jibianyoujiufen,yinweizhengcemingque,nizhishaokeyiquqisu,erqiefayuantongchanghuizhichi。xiangwomenzhiqianqusichuanguangan,dangdiyouzhengdichaiqian,wojiuwencunmin,“nvxingjiehunhouhukouhailiuzainiangjia,chaiqianfenleyitaofang,dajiahuibuhuiyouyijian?”cunminjiuhuishuo,“neiyoushenme,zhiyaorenjiahukouzaizheili,bierenmeideshuo。”

zaibirushanxixian,2003nian,chengshihuajinchengjiakuai,chuxianlehenduozhengdichaiqianjiufen,chujianvdesuqiujiejuebule,dangshi1000duoweichujianvquweigongfayuan,hentouteng。2004nian,xianshizhongjirenminfayuanjiuchutaileneibuguiding,zhidingleyigerendingchengyuanzigedebiaozhun,zheiyangchujianvdewentijiujiejuele。womenyecongweijiedaoguoxiandetousu。

lingwaihaiyouanhuishenggaoyuan、hainanshenggaoyuan……doushizai2004nian、2008nianzuoyou,zhuanmenzhenduiyongxianchudechujianvdejiufen,chutailezhengce。suoyiyouzhengceyijuhaishibuyiyang,yinweifayuanshizuihouyidaofangxian,youleyiju,fayuanjiukeyipanan。

shenzhiyoushihou,yangzhangdejiushikaimingdeguanyuan。nanninggaoxinquguanweihuiyouyirenzhuren,jiuduichujianvtebietongqing,shangtaizhihou,jiejuelechujianvdewenti。wokanguoyigeshipin,tafabiaojianghua,zhendeshihenganren,nihuijuedeyouzheiyangdeganbu,weilaishiyouxiwangde。dantazhizairenshangsannian,houlaijiudiaodaoxianliqule,zheigezhengceyejiuzhongduanle。

jingguozheixieshiqing,womenhoulaiyeyishidao,jiranhaimeiyouchutaijutidefalv,chujianvdewenti,guangkaosusong,yiyibuda——womenyinggaihuanyizhongfangshi,zhaoyixiediqu,tongguozuoxiangmudefangshi,zixiaershangtuidonglifadewanshan。

yibanlaishuo,womenshiheshengshijifulianhuozhengfuhezuo,zaijicengdefulian、zhengfu、fayuanyijiyoudecunzhuanglaizuoshidian,tuidongdifangzhengfu、fayuanchutaixiangguanwenjian,tuidongshidiancunxiudingcunguiminyue。

hebeixingtaishizhongjirenminfayuan,jiushiwomenzuoguodeyigebijiaochenggongdeshidian。2004nianzhiqian,xingtaizhongyuanneibuyouwenjianguiding,chujianvdeanjiangaibushouli,2007nianwomenyejiedaoguoxingtaichujianvdeqiuzhu。dangshiqicaoneigewenjiandefaguanjiaomaweidong,shiminshifatingdetingzhang。womengangquxingtaizuopeixun,tahendichu,juedejiushibugaishouli,dantayehenshanyuxuexi、shanyutiwen,gezhongguannianjiukaishidajia——houlai,tadeguannianjiumanmangaibianle,juedehaishiyinggaishouli,youyoutaqicaoleyifenxinwenjian,guidingzheileianjianzenmeshouli,shenmeqingkuangxiayinggaibaoliuquanli,xiedehenmingque。2010nian1yue1hao,zheigeguidingchutaile。tadanxinzheigeguidingbuhaozhixing,shenzhihaizhudongshenqingdiaodaozhixingjuzuolejuzhang,henrangrengandong。

邢台中院马维东法官在培训中解析新规定。图 / 讲述者提供

zaiquanguo,xiudingcunguiminyue,zuodezuizao、zuodezuihaodeyinggaishihenandengfengshizhoushancun,shihenandeliangjunlaoshi、zhongyangdangxiaodelihuiyingdengjiweilaoshishengengduoniandejieguo。

womenzuocunguiminyue,qishibuyidingzhijieqierutudiquan,yinweinizhijietitudiquan,henduorenhuijuedemingan,huijujue。henduoshihou,womenshicongyanglaowentilaiqieru。yanglaoshinongcunhenguanzhudewenti,suowei“yangerfanglao”,danshiyangerzhennengfanglaoma?nverjinleyanglaoyiwuma?yingbuyinggaifenjiachan?

liangjunlaoshidetuanduijiuzuoleyigeyanglaohuatimonifatingdeshipin,jiangdejiushiguanyunongcunshanyanglaorenhefenpeijiachandejiufengushi——youyiduilaorenyanglelianggeerzi、yigenver,laorendesuoyoujixudoujilianggeerzimaifangquqi,dengdaolaolebingle,erzimenshigezhongtuituo,nverquexiangfangshefachoushijiansihoufumu,fencaichandeshihou,nverqueyidiandoudebudao,tatebieshangxin。zheiyangdegushizainongcunhenpubian。wenticengcengfenxixialai,dajiajiufaxian,nverjindeshanyangyiwububierzishao,quebufencaichan,queshibugongping。womenmeicizuopeixun,douhuibofangzheigeshipin,henduoxiangzhenganbu、cunganbukanledouhenshouzhenhan,huiliulei。

congcunjitidejiaodulaishuo,yeshiyiyangde。cunjitiduicunlidenverheerzi,shibushipingdeng?ruguobupingdeng,neidajiadouxiangshengerzi。danzheiyangyilai,erziyuelaiyueduo,zuihoudouqubushangxifu,cailiyeyuelaiyuegao。womenjiuconggenyuanshanglaifenxita,yeshixiwanggencunmintaolun,rangdajiakankan,nengbunenggaibianyixieguannian,bapingdengdeguizexiejincunguiminyueliqu。houlaitamendoutongyile。

(2009nianzhoushancunxiudingdecunguiminyue,beichengwei“woguolishishangshoubujuyouxingbiepingdengneirongdecunguiminyue”,congxuduofangmianqingchulecunzhuangqishinvxingde“qianguize”,jutitiaokuanruxia:

chunnvhu、youeryounvhudezinvhunjiaziyou,nandaonvjia、nvdaonanjiajunke,xiangshoubencuncunmindaiyu;

hunchunannvyinlihunhuosangou,jianghukouqianhuibencunzhexiangshoucunmindaiyu;

zhichi、gulifunvcanzhengyizheng,zaihuanjiexuanjuzhong,nvxingdangxuancunmindaibiaobushaoyu50%;ruxuancunliangwei、cunminzuzhangyijiqitacunminyishijigoudebilibudiyusanfenzhiyi;

tichangwenmingjiejiandehunli,fannandaonvjiadehunli,cunliangweidalizhichibingxiezhucaoban;

fuqizaijiatingzhongdiweipingdeng,gongtongchengdanjiawulaodong;

tichangzinvxingshiziyou,suifuxing、suimuxinghuofumushuangxingjunke。)

西宁出嫁女失地后租住的平房。图 / 讲述者提供

代价

xinfameichulaizhiqian,2018nianzuoyou,shiwomenzuijuewangdeshihou——dangshilaiqiuzhudenvxing,youdeyijingzouwanlesusongchengxu,quanbubaisu;youdemeizouwansusongchengxu,yinweifayuanbushouli。youxieanjian,womenhuiquzhaodangdizhengfuxiediaojiejue,youxiezhengfukenengkeqikeqi,jiedaiwomen,yehuishuokaolvzenmejiejue。danwomenyihuilaijiumeixiawenle。

youqishilaoyidainvxingdewenti,jiejueqilaifeichangnan。tamendaduowenhuashuipingbijiaodi,fangfabudedang,biruquweiquanshibudaicailiao,yemeiyouzhengju:cunlizhengleduoshaodi,qizhongyouniduoshaodi,fenpeifanganzenyang?tamentongchangdoubuqingchu。duoshushihouzhishikoutouquzhao,renjiajijuhuajiubatamendafale,meiliuxiarenhewenzihuifu,yincibunengzhengmingtamenyizhizaiweiquan,qisushi,henkenengyiguosusongshixiao。weiquanguochengtaikunnan,daduoshurenmanmanjiufangqile,zhiyoushaoshurenhainengjianchi,youfangfahezhihui,yeyuanyifuchudaijia。

danshinihaishihuikandaozaimanzhangdeshijianzhong,tamenderenshengshizenmemosunde。tamenshiquleqingchun、jiankang,youhenduorenzuihouyelilehun。

woqianmiantidaodeneimenggubayannaoerdeyangzhijun,dangshitahetameimeiyiqiweiquan。juyangzhijunshuo,zhengfudangshifenjitamen7fendekouliangtian,danshicunlirenweilebiaodabuman,tamenzhongshenme,cunmindouqubadiao。zuihoutamentiantianwanshangjiushuizaidilishouzhe,shentishouchaojiashanglaolei,houlaitameimeideleshenbing,40duosuijiuqushile。

yangzhijundangshihuaishanglediergehaizi,yeshiyicihecunmindejiufen,tabeidale,duifangbuzhidaotahuaiyunle。houlaitajiuqubaotai,yongleyao,haizimeiliuchan,haishishengxialaile,danfayudebuhao,liangsuiduojiuqushile。zhendeshifuchuletaidadedaijia。

zhejiangtaizhouyougechujianv,tayoudidi,danhaishixiangzhengquzijidezhaijidi。guoqu20nian,tazaiwaijianvquntilihenhuoyue,shiyigezuzhizhe,renyehennenggan,qishizaizhejiangsuibianzuodianshengyi,dounengshengcunxiaqu,danshitaxuanzeleweiquan。

qianduanshijianwomenlianxita,tagenwoshuo,tahouhuile,shiquleyiqie——lihunle,youmeiyouhaizi,haideleaizheng,shentihenxuruo。taquanjiadoubuzhichita,chuchushoudayahepaichi。xianzaitagukulingdingyigeren,duzizaiwaimianzufangshenghuo。womendangshixiangrangyiweitaizhoujishixishengqukankanta,tayeshifeichanggulv,shuowomenshixishengshinansheng,tapazuolinyoushekandaoyouyixinglai,huishuoxianhua。tajiuzheiyangdanzhanxinjingdiguozherizi。

zaizhejiangdongyang,youyiweigengnianqingdechujianv,tayeshiyouyigedidi,zuikaishi,tadidizaiwaimiandagong,shuozijibuhuihuilaojiale,jialijiudachenggongshi,rangtazhaoxu,liuzaijialishenghuo。danshiguolejinian,didiyoujuedinghuilaile,henkuaijiujielehun,jialijiuburangtazhule,rangtahezhangfunverbanchuqu。taxiangyaoyigezhaijidi,zaicunlijianfangzi,cunliyebuyuanyi。

dangshiwomenqudaotajia,tadejiarenfeichangqiangying。womenxianggentamentantan,tamamahedidijujuejianmian,tababahaodaichuxianle,danwanquantingbujinhua,youyanbujin,yizhishuo,tajiadesuoyoucaichandoushierzihesunzide。zaifumumianqian,tawanquanshishoudayade,shenmehuadoubuganshuo。

dangshitadezhuangtaiyefeichangzhiao,shineizhongzhangqiweiquanshibaizhihoudeyingjizhuangtai。womendanfanyoudianfanduitadeyijian,tajiubugaoxing。dangshitanvercai3sui,henmingxianyebeimamayingxiangle,kanrendeshihou,yeshineizhongdishideyanshen,womenxiangjitayidiantang,tayeshifeichangziwobaohu。

womenshenzhijiejuezheigewentidenandu,xiwangmiaomang,suoyijiuquantashuo,niquzhaogegongzuoba,xianbazijideshenghuogaohao。womenlejieleyixia,zaidangdikaichuzuche,yigeyuedounengzheng9000duokuaiqian,tinghao,shijianyeziyou,danshitashuotabugankaiche。

(2023nian,meirirenwuzuozhecengqudaozhejiang,jiandaolejiweichujianv。dangshiguanchadaotamenjiatingneibudemouxiegongxing:zheixiechujianvdezhangfu,wangwangzaiweiquanzheijianshiqingshangdoushichenmode,tamenbuzuzhiqizizuozheijianshi,danyebuzhichi、bubiaotai、bucanyu。womenyuqizimenliaotianshi,tamenshijialiyigehuisedebeiying。shiquanrucixianxing,dantamenxiwanghulveta,jixushenghuoxiaqu。

dongyangzheiweichujianvshenzhitidao,youduanshijian,tadezhangfubuxiangyaozheigejiatingle,tashi“zijitieshangqu”,jinliweichihetadeguanxi。tayitaishengdeshinver,weileliuzhuzhangfu,tayoushengleertai,shigeerzi。tashuo,erzichushengzhihou,“laogongdexindingxialaile”。)

womenshijuede,duisuoyoudechujianvlaishuodouyiyang——tudiquanyiwenti,bushizhenduimougeren,shiyigexitongxingdewenti。gerendenuli,queshihuituidongshehuijinbu、tuidongfazhijinbu,yinggaiyouzheiyangderenchuxian。danquequeshishi,tadechengbentebieda,fuchutebieduo,nihuidedaoshenmeyangdehuibao,sheidoubuzhidao。

suoyiyinggaixianbazijideshenghuogaohao,buyaoyiyiguxing,zhizuozheiyijianshi。yinweizheiyangdehua,nibazijideyishengdajinqu,xishengdiaojiankanghexingfu,douweibinengzhengdehuilai。dangranle,tamenyouxuanzedeziyou。ruguotamenzheimexuan,womenyidinghuitigonglisuonengjidebangzhu。

与女村官交谈。图 / 讲述者提供

“最好、最适合的法律”

suoyidaole2020nian,womentingshuo《nongcunjitijingjizuzhifa》beilierulifajihua,dangrangandaohengaoxing,juedekandaolexiwang。zhiqianmeiyoutaizhongshita,yemeixiangdaotuijinhuizheimekuai。

jingguozheimeduonian,womenhenmingbai,guanyuchujianvdetudiwenti,zuihaojiushiyouquanguorendatongyilifa,zhidingmingqueqiejutideguiding——yinweiwoguoshichengwenfaguojia,zhiyoufalvguidingle,youmingquedeyiju,zheiyangjiuhenshun,wulunshidifangzhengfuhefayuan,chulijiufendeshihoujiuyouyijukexunle。

guoquqitafalvlifashi,womendouyouguoqidai。zhiqian《nongcuntudichengbaofa》xiuding,womenqidaitanengdui“sheiyouquanlichengbaotudi”zuoguiding。yixieguanzhuxingbiewentidefalvzhuanjiadangshijiutiguo,yaokaolvdaohunjiadenvxing。tamenjiadaopojiazhihou,fenzainiangjiadetudidaibuzou,tudihetongqixiandongzhejiu20、30nian,zheizenmeban?cunjitiyinggaiyaoyuliuyibufentudi,buyaofenwan,baozhanghunjiadefunvyenengfendaodi。dandangshidelifazhejuede,yinggaibaochizhonglidezitai,“fanzhengnannvdouzaiyigejiali,nizainiangjiashi,xiangyouzheigejiadetudi,daolepojia,jiuxiangshoupojiade”,zheijiushixiangdangranle。

houlai《funvquanyibaozhangfa》xiuding,womenyeyouguoqidai,dantayoushidaerquande、changdaoxingdefalv,bukenengjiuyigewentiguidingdehenxi。erqiezaiwoguodesifashijianzhong,zheibufalvhenduoshihoububeishiyong。faguanhuijuede,zhiyoujiatingbaoli、xingsaorao,caishifunvwenti,dannongcuntudiwenti,yijitijingjizuzhiweizhu,bushifunvwenti。

suoyi《nongcunjitijingjizuzhifa》lierulifajihua,womenzhendehengaoxing——tashizuihao、zuishihejiu“chengyuanzige”wentizuochuguidingdefalv,erqieshishouciguiding。ruguoguidingdejuti、xiangxi、kecaozuo,keyimibujishinianlaidequeshi。

erqiefangzihetudi,jiushinongcunzuidadeliyi,zaizheigewentishang,ruguonannvpingdeng,neidajiabuhuizaihushengerhaishishengnv,duiyujiuzhengnanhaipianhao,huifeichangyoubangzhu,cailiwenti、yanglaowentizhubudouhuidedaojiejue。tadeyiyishifeichangdade,danqiantishi,zheitiaofalvyaoguidinghao。

suoyizai2022niandi,《nongcunjitijingjizuzhifa(caoan)》chutai,kaishixiangshehuizhengqiuyijiandeshihou,womenhenkuaijiuduwanlecaoanquanwen,yewenlehenduochujianvdexiangfa,zuihoutichulewomendexiugaiyijian,huyudajiayiqitijiao。

zheifencaoanyouhenrangrenjingxidebufen,youqishidierzhang“chengyuan”bufen,yongjinshigetiaowenguidinglenongcunjitijingjizuzhichengyuandedingyi、queren、quanli、yiwu、tuichu、baoliudengdengredianwenti,shizhenzhengweifalvzhurulelinghun。

danwomenjuede,tayeyouyixiekeshangquezhichu:

birudishiertiao,guanyuchengyuanquedingwenti,shizheimeguidingde,“anzhaozunzhonglishi、jianguxianshi、chengxuguifan、qunzhongrenkedeyuanze,tongchoukaolvhujiguanxi、nongcuntudichengbaoguanxi、shengchanshenghuoqingkuang、jibenshenghuobaozhanglaiyuan、duijitijileidegongxiandengyinsu”。

womendangshiyikan,suowei“zunzhonglishi”“qunzhongrenke”dengdeng,jialezheimeduoxiandingtiaojian,shibushishuo,yiqiancunminmenrendingmougechujianvbuxiangshouquanli,neiyihouyeyinggaizunzhongzheigejuece?xianshizhong,wanquankeyiyongzheixietiaokuanlaizuankongzi。womendangshijiuzheigetiaokuantilexiugaiyijian。

zaibirucaoandishijiutiao“busangshichengyuanshenfendeqingxing”,taguiding“funvchengyuanbuyinsangou、lihunersangshijitijingjizuzhichengyuanshenfen”。danshijishang,henduonongcundiqu,dalingweihun、jiehun、zaihundenvxing,yehuibeipaichuzaijitizhiwai。suoyiwomenjiujianyi,bazheitiaogaicheng“funvchengyuanbuyinweihun、jiehun、sangou、lihun、zaihundengersangshijitijingjizuzhichengyuanshenfen”。

shuoshihua,henduoshihou,womentizheixiejianyi,qishiyebuquedingnengbunengbeicaina。danwomenyiranyaoti,yaoxiechulai,baliyouxiedehenchongfen,yinweizheiyeshiyizhongxuanchuanhejiaoyu。

zhenzhengdao2024nian6yue,《nongcunjitijingjizuzhifa》gongbu,womenfaxianlifazhehaishicainalehenduojianyi,duichengyuanzigedeguiding,yigongyoujiutiao,bijiaomingque,biwomenxiangxiangzhongyaohaohenduo。

qizhongmingquetidao,nongcunjitijingjizuzhichengyuan,“buyinwugong、jingshang、lihun、sangoudengyuanyinsangshishenfen”——womenjianguohenduoanli,nvxingjiushiyinweizheixieyuanyin,beiboduolequanyi;haiyouyitiaoguiding,shuojitijingjizuzhidechengyuan,ruguojiehunle,danmeiyouzaiqitadifangqudechengyuanshenfen,neimeyuancunjiti,yebunengquxiaotadeshenfen,zheitiaoyeshiduihunjianvxingyoulide。

erqiedinggaohaizhuanmentidaolefunvquanyi,“funvxiangyouyunanzipingdengdequanli”,zheixiangdangyushiba《funvquanyibaozhangfa》lideneirongyiguolaile,zheihenrangrenxinwei,shihenyoubiyao、yehenhaodeyidian。

xinfagongbuneitian,henduochujianvdouhenxingfen,youqishiguangxi、guangdong、shandongdenvxing,tamenzijidedaiyukenengjiejuele,danzinvyizhidoushibeipaichide。erxinfamingqueguidingle,“duiyinchengyuanshengyuerzengjiaderenyuan……yingdangquerenweinongcunjitijingjizuzhichengyuan”。henduorengenwoshuo,neitiantamenhenwandoumeishuizhe。

在江苏省试点村修订村规民约讨论会的现场。图 / 讲述者提供

隐忧与期待

xinfa2025nian5yue1haoshengxiao,dancongjinnianxiatiantagongbukaishi,youxiedifang,yijingyoulesongdong。

zaineimenggutongliao,jiuyouyigeanzi,shejidaocunlidetudibuchangkuan,meiniancunlidoufa,zuijinzheici,meiweicunmindounengfayiwanyuan,dantamenzhifenjichujianv500yuan。quancunyou75weichujianv,tamendangranbutongyi,houlaijianchajiguanjieru,qugencunjitixiediaogoutong,diaojiezhihoudejieguoshi——zheicideyiwanyuan,chujianvdounengxiangyou,nanxingcunminnaduoshao,tamenjiunaduoshao。

danyinweifalvmingniancaishengxiao,shuyutamendezhei75wanyuan,cunjitiyijingfangzaileyigezhuanmendezhanghushang,dengmingnian5yue1ri,《nongcunjitijingjizuzhifa》yishengxiao,zheiqianjiujitamen。

xianzaiwomenduixinfazuidadedanyou,jiuzaiyudishiertiaodiyikuan:“nongcunjitijingjizuzhitongguochengyuandahui,yijuqiantiaoguidingquerennongcunjitijingjizuzhichengyuan”,yisihaishishuo,chengyuanzigehaishiyoucunminzizhi,jikaicunmindahui,shaoshufucongduoshulaijueding。womenduixianshibijiaolejie,danxinzheitiaofalv,huichengweichujianvzhengququanlishizuidadezuai。

jugelizi,jinnianwomenquleyitangshandong,dangdiyougeanli,shigeshuangnvhujiating,fuqinyinweizhongnanqingnv,henzaojiuheqizilihunle,qulewaidi,zuchenglexinjiating,zheiweimuqinjiudaizhelianggenverzaicunlijixushenghuo,danverhaizaicunlizhaolexu。houlaizheiweifuqindaizheerhundeqizi、erzihuilaile,cunlijiugendanvershuo,niyoudidile,neinijiushichujianv,buxiangshoucunmindaiyule,boduoletadequanyi。zhiqiantameiniannengfendaozhengdihezudikuan,houlaijiumeiyoule。

zheigenverbufu,quqisu,fayuanpantashengsule,danshishuyutadeqian,yizhiwufaluoshi。womenjiuqudangdi,xiangkankandaodizenmehuishi,daolezhihoufaxian,yinweitaqisule,cunminduitajiayijianhenda。kaicunmindahui,dajiadoubutongyibaqianjita;tadagongzanqianmaideyiliangche,beirenzale;gebiyiweinanxingcunminheledianjiu,jiumatamama,shuotalaizaicunlibuzou,fendajiadecaichan,haibatamamadale;tamamayebeicunganbutichulecunlideweixinqun,taxiangwendianshenmeshi,cunlirendoubulita。jiushizheiyangyizhongfenwei,tamenyijiashihenshougulide。

youyitianwanshang,womenzaicunliliuda,heyixiecunminliaotian。buguanshinanxingcunminhaishinvxingcunmin,tamendoushishuo,“zaiwomennongcun,falvpanyingle,yemeiyong,womendoushianzhaotubanfalai。(suoyouquanyi)chujianvdoushibunengyoude。yaoshidoujifen,neisuoyounvhaijiehunhoudoubuzoule。”

jingliguoleisideshiqing,womenjiuhuijuede,ruguohaishiyouchengyuandahuilaiquerenchengyuanshenfen,huiyouqianzaidefengxian——yudaobujianglidecunjiti,jinjin“cunminzizhi”zheiyitiao,jiukeyituifansuoyoujinbu。womendangranxiwangsuoyoucunmindouyuanyigaibian,danfalvbunengjixiwangyurendedaode。youqishidangliyihendadeshihou。

suoyiwomenxianghuyudeshi,mingnian5yue《nongcunjitijingjizuzhifa》shixinghou,nengchutaigengxizhideshishibanfa,huozhenengzhenduiyouxietiaokuan,zuogengxizhidesifajieshi。womendangranzunzhongcunminzizhi,danruguo,cunminzizhizuochulebugongzhengdejueding,fayuankeyitongguopanjuezuohefaxingshencha,zhengfukeyitongguoxingzhengjuedingshuyifajiucuo,erbushizaituihuijicunminzizhi。

rangneixiexiangzunshoufalvderen,youfakeyi。rangneixiebuzunshoufalvderen,dedaochengfa。yerangneixieshiquanderen,dedaojiuji。

dangran,falvyongyuanshidixian,genggenbendehaishizaijiaqiangnongcundiqudexuanchuan,rangdajiashulixingbiepingdengdeguannian。zhiyouguannianzhuanbianle,falvcaihuiyoutadeturang。

qishizheijianshikeyihenjiandan。woxiangjiangyige20nianqiandegushi。dangshijiaoyubuyougeguiding,daxueshengbenkejieduanbunengjiehun,yanjiushengheboshijieduanbunengshenghaizi。2004nian7yuedeyitian,wojiedaileyiweinvboshi。

dangshita30sui,hezhangfudouzaibeijingyisuoxuexiaodubo,yeshiyiwaihuaiyunle,tadeshentibudahao,yishengjianyitabahaizishengxialai。qishitayijingjiehunle,youshidiyitai,wanquanfuhe《hunyinfa》he《jihuashengyufa》,dandangshijiushiyinweijiaoyubudeguiding,xuexiaojiubatakaichule。danshitazhangfumeishi,haizaijixudubo。

dangshiwomenyougeguwen,zhongguorenmindaxuedeyangdawenjiaoshou,shizhongguohunyinfaxuededianjirenzhiyi,tabianzhulezhongguodiyibuhunyinjiatingfajiaocai,yeshi1980nian《hunyinfa》he1992nian《funvquanyibaozhangfa》deqicaozuchengyuan,tadangshitebiezhichizheigenvshengquqisu。dantakaolvdaozhangfuhaizaidushu,bugan,fangqile。

womenjiuzhenduizheiqianjian,zhaokaileyigeyantaohui,qinglemeiti、zhuanjiaxuezhe、gaoxiaoguanlizhelaikaihui,dangshijiaoyubudeguanyuanyelaile。tazaixianchangshuo,shinianqian,tamenjiuxiangquxiaozheigeguiding,danyouhaipaquxiaozhihou,xuexiaochengleyuyingtang。nvhaizishangdaxuejiujiehun,yanjiushengjiushenghaizi,jiaoyujihuadouyaobeidaluan,haoxiangyidanzhengcefangkai,jiuhuichuhendaluanziside。

huihou,meitiduizheigehuiyizuolebaodao,yigeyuehou,jiaoyubujiubazheigeguidingquxiaole(2005nian3yueguojiajiaoyubugongbuxinban《putonggaoxiaoxueshengguanliguiding》,quxiaoledaxueshengjiehunxujingxuexiaotongyidejiuguiding)。zheimeduonianguoqule,shishizhengming,daxuebingmeiyouchengweiyuyingtang。rendoushilixingde,nvhaizibuhuiyinweizheigeguidingbucunzaile,jiusuisuibianbianjizheshenghaizi。

tongyangdedaoli,nongcundenvhaizi,bingbuhuiyinweiyoulequanyi,jiuquandouliuzaicunlibuzou。tamenyaojincheng、dushu、zhaogongzuo,renshilixingde、liudongde。danzuizhongyaode,shiwomenyinggaijitamenxuanzedeziyouhequanli。

本文为转载内容,授权事宜请联系原著作权人。

评论

暂无评论哦,快来评价一下吧!

下载界面新闻

微信公众号

农村妇女土地权,漫长的抗争仍在继续

“zuizhongyaodeshiyinggaijitamenzijixuanzedequanli。”

wen | meirirenwushe linsongguo

编辑 | 姚璐

yunying | xiaolu xiaoerlang

2024nian6yue28ri,jingguosancishenyi,《zhonghuarenmingongheguonongcunjitijingjizuzhifa》zuizhongtongguo,jiangyu2025nian5yue1rizhengshishengxiao。zheishiyibu“qianhuwanhuanshichulai”defalv,tagongbuneitian,zaiquanguohenduodifang,henduonvxingshenyeweimian,tamenzaixiangxiang,xinfajiangruhegaibianzijidemingyun。

guoquzheixienian,nongcunfunvdetudiquanyi,chengleyigezongyouzhengyiquechichiwufajiejuedewenti。nongcunzaifazhan,zuoweiyigejitijingjizuzhi,tahuiyudaochaiqian、fenhong……erzuoweicunzhuanglidenvxing,changchangyindalingweihun、jiehun、lihun、sangoudengyuanyinbeiduoquan。2023nian8yue,yiweizhejiangnvxingdeweibobeizhuanfaguo2.6wanci——tayinyuwaidinanxingjiehun,chengle“chujianv”,yizhangbobodejiehunzheng,tashiqule120100yuandetudizhengyongkuan。

zheibufalv,shilishishangdiyicidui“heweinongcunjitijingjizuzhichengyuan”zuochuguiding:“funvxiangyouyunanzipingdengdequanli,budeyifunvweihun、jiehun、lihun、sangou、huwunanxingdengweiyou,qinhaifunvzainongcunjitijingjizuzhizhongdegexiangquanyi。”tadechutai,huoxuhuigaibianmouxiexianshi,rangshiquanzhededaojiuji。

linlixiashibeijingqianqianlvsuofunvtudiquanyixiangmudefuzeren,guoqu20duonian,zaibeijingbeisihuanyijianjuminlougaizaoerchengdebangongshili,tahetongshimenjiedaoguochaoguo3000weinongcunnvxingdeqiuzhu,jinjisuonengweitamenbenzou,danzuihounengshengsudenvxing,buzuyicheng。

zheishiyitiaomanzhang、jiannandedaolu。meirirenwucengquwangzhejiangheguangdong,jiandaolejiwei“chujianv”。tamenyoudexiangdangnianqing,gangyinweijiehunershiquletudibuchangkuan,yanlihaiyoubuganhezhengzheng;youdebeijiarenhecunzhuang“quzhu”,modemeilexinqi,wojuzaihunandechuzufangli;haiyoudezhuzaicunzhuangbianyuan,dangwomenzouzaicunli,tahuisuoqibozisongzhejian,xiaoxinyiyidiliuzhebianer。danxiangtongdeshi,tamendoujianxin,zijibuyinggaiyinweixingbieershiquan。

ruhejiangzheixiebugan,zhuanhuaweigaibianxianshideliliang?zheixienian,linlixiahetadetongshimenzuoledaliangdegongzuo,shitujianliyitiaogoutongtujing。tamenweijicengnvxingweiquan,yetongguodaliangdexinxi、shuju、ziliaoheyantaohui,jinliyingxiangjuececeng。tamenzaicunzhuangtuiguangjuyoupingdengshijiaodecunguiminyue,yeshitutongguodifangfayuanhefulian,gaibianjubudexiaoqihou。

2023nianchu,《zhonghuarenmingongheguonongcunjitijingjizuzhifa(caoan)》gongkaixiangshehuizhengqiuyijian,linlixiayuqianqianlvsuodetongshimen,diyishijiantijiaolexiugaijianyi,youshangwanrenzhuanfa。

zhihouwomenyigongjianguolinlixiasanci,fangtanchaoguo10xiaoshi,womenliaoqizhei20niantajianguodeneixienvxing,tamenderouruanyujueqiang,weilezhengququanyi,tamenzuoguonaxienuli,yijiweiraonongcunfunvtudiquandefazhixijie。

meicijianmian,linlixiajirendeyinxiangdoushihengdingde:tashoushoude,bangzhemawei,zaiwendubugaodebangongshiliguozheyurongfu,shouwoyibeicha。wulunwomentandaodeneirongruhejingxindongpo,rangrenfennuhuotanxi,tazongshixiandepingjing、jianding,shaoyoujiliedeqingxubiaoda。huoxuzhengshizheiyangyizhonghengdingdejingshenliliang,cainengzhichiyigeren、yigezuzhi,zaizheiyangyijianshiqingshangjianchi20nianzhijiu。

yixiashilinlixiadejiangshu:

不婚也失权,结婚也失权,离婚也失权

woshisichuanren,zuizaoshizailaojiadeyisuozhongxuezuoshengwulaoshi。zongshikandaobugongpingdeshiqing,jiuxiwangnengzouchulai,nengjiandegengduo。1995nianwolaidaobeijingxueyingyu,yeshihenouran,1997nian,yiweilaoshituijianwodaoqianqianlvsuo(dangshijiaobeidafaxueyuanfunvfalvyanjiuyufuwuzhongxin)gongzuo。wojuedezheigegongzuomanyouyiside,yishikeyibangzhunvxing,ershikeyilejieshehui,jiuliuxialaile。

zuichuwoshicongxingzhenggongzuozuoqi,bingzaizhidulefalvdeyanjiusheng,zhihoukaishixiezhulvshicanyuanjianbanli。zaizheigeguochengzhong,nihuikandaoshidaiyitibuduanbianhua:congfunvzhuixintaochoudenglaodongquandewenti,daolihunhaizifuyang、caichanfengedenghunyinjiatingwenti,zaidaojiatingbaoli、zhichangxingsaorao,zuihou,wokaishifuzenongcunfunvtudiquanxiangmu。

dagaishi2005nianzuoyou,jiuzaizheigebangongshi,congnanninglailejishigeren,doushichujianv。dangshitamenzhuangkuanghenbuhao,meidifangzhu,nanfangbajiaoyebushihendama?tamenjiukandianmaozhu、shugan,zaishangmiangaishangbajiaoye,zhefengdangyu,yijiarenjiuzheimeshengcun。dangshijirendezhenhanshitingdade。

2005nianshiyigebijiaozhongyaodeshijianjiedian。dangshichengshihuajinchengjiakuai,fazhandezaodeguangdong、guangxizheixiediqu,chujianvdejiufenyijingyoule,neiludiquchengzhenhuajianshekaishi,yeyoulezhengdi、chaiqiananzhiwenti,womenjiukaishijiedaolaiziquanguogedideqiuzhudianhua。tamenyoudeshikandaolemeitibaodao,youdeshikoukouxiangchuan,jiuzheimezhaoguolaile。

“chujianv”quntiqishishihendade,yinweiweihun、jiehun、sangou、lihun、zaihunersangshilequanlidenvxing,doukeyibeichengweichujianv——xianshijiushizheimedingyide——nimeijiehun,danzhiyaojialiyouerzi,nizhongjiudoushiyaochujiade;jielehun,nijiushuyufujiale;nisangoule,tamenyejuede,nikendinghuizaihun;lihunleyeshiyiyang。zongdelaishuo,nvxinghuiyinweihunyinerliudong,tamendequanli,yeyinweizheizhongliudong,erdebudaobaozhang。

gezhongshiquandeqingkuang,womendouyudaoguo:

meijiehunjiushiquande——zaihunanxiangtan,yougecundecunguiminyuejiuguiding,“nianman28zhousuideweihunnvxing,budecanyurenhefenpei”。cunliyougejiating,you3genverhe1geerzi,dangshidanveryijiehun,hukouweiqianchu,jiehunhoujiushiqulefenpeiquan;linglianggenver,man28suizhihou,yebeiquxiaoledaiyu。lianggexiaonverbufuqi,quqisu,fayuanhaipantamenshengsule,rangcunlibazhengdibuchangkuanjitamen,qishimeirenyejiuyiliangqiankuaiqian,dancunlijiushibuji。

dangshiwohewodetongshiquledangdi,womenjiuxiangzhidao,weishenmebuzhixing?cunlidezhanghu,guixiangzhencaizhengsuoguanli,womenjiuqucha,cunlidaodiyoumeiyouqian,faxianhutoushangqueshimeiqian,danyougechujianvfaxian,ei,zenmewomencunzheigerenhutoushangyou300wan?shijishang,cunliguyibaqiannuodaolezheirendezhangshang。womenjiugenxiangzhentan,weishenmebunengqiangzhizhixingni,xiangzhenjiushuo,zhiqiancunjitideganbudaizhehenduonanxingcunminlaiguole,tamenshuo,xiangzhenyaoshiganjiqian,tamendaoshihoujiulaiweigongxiangzhenzhengfu。zhengfuyehaipa,chujianvbijingshishaoshu,erzheigecun,shijiqianrendeliyigongtongti。

下乡调研时,林丽霞访谈村书记。图 / 讲述者提供

jielehunjiushiquande——zaihubeitianmen,yougejiatingyoulianggehaizi,gegeshicunhuiji,meimeishigaoducanji,meimeizheizhongqingkuang,zaidangdizhaoduixianghennan,danzheidifangbijiaofuyu,jiuzhaoleyigepianyuannongcundexiaohuoziruzhui,hukouyeqianguolaile,haishenglelianggehaizi,meimeizijiyenenggan,shigecaifeng。houlaiyudaozhengdichaiqian,cunlijiuburentazheiyijia。

womendangshiyequle,xiangzhenganbujiushuo,“nikan,liantagegedoubutongyiji。”womenjiuwentagege,weishenmebutongyi?tagegeshuo,ruguojile,neiyihoudajiajiehunhoudoubuyuanyizoule,bunengyinweitayouteshuqingkuang,jiuewaizhaogu。tamenjiujuede,suoyoudenvxing,zhiyaojialiyouerzi,nijiehunzhihoudouyinggaizou,quanliqupojiaxiangyou。zheishitamengenshendigudeguannian。

haiyouzaihunnvxingdesuiqianzinvshiquande——guangxinanningdegenvshijiwomendadianhuaqiuzhu,shuotamamadaizhetahedidi,jiajilejifu,danshihoulaimuqinhejifudouqushile。jifuyizou,cunlijiuhenpaichitamen,bujitamencunmindaiyu,shuotamenbushizheigecundexuemai。jinguanzaifalvshang,jizinv、hefashouyangdezinv,heqinshengzinvdequanlishiyiyangde。dancunlibuguan,tamenhaishirenkexuemaiguanxi。

zhiqianzai《yixi》deyanjiangzhongwoshuoguo,“dangzheixieshiqutudidefunvzhanchulaiweiquanshi,tamenwangwanghuibianchengyigejiating、yigecunzhuangdediren”,zheishizhende。womenzhenzhengqudaocunli,qubanzheixieanzi,nijiuhuiganjuedao,zuliqueshihenda,shenzhihuiyudaocunminlaiweigong。

wojide2014nian,wohezhongyangdangxiaodelihuiyinglaoshi,quqinghaiyigecunzi,xiangxiediaojiejuechujianvdechaiqiananzhiwenti。quzhiqianjiuzhidao,kenenghennan,maoduntaishenle,dangdifayuanyebushoulichujianvdesuqiu。zheigecundenanxingcunmin,meirenanzhiyitaofang,fumuyeyouyitao,yijialianggeerzi,jiuyousantaofang,neifangziwomenkanle,queshihenhao。danshichujianvjiushenmedoumeiyou,tamenzhinengpaodaohenbianyuandechengjiao,zudeshi100kuaiqianyigeyuedepopingfang。

womendaocunli,xiangzhaocunganbuliaoyiliao。faxiantongwangcunliangweibangongshideloudao,youyidaodatiemen,genbenshangbuqu,renjiaxianwenniyoushenmeshi,zaijiushuo,renbuzai。zouzaicunli,renjiadoushiyongyiyangdeyanguanglaikanwomen,nideyizhe,nibeidebao,tamenjiuzhidaonishiwailaideren,buyuanyigennishuohua。

在青海省的村子里调研。图 / 讲述者提供

“分明是我自己的权利,为什么别人来表决?”

weishenmechujianvweiquanzheimenan,2004nianwomenkaishijieshoudaliangzheileianjian,henkuaijiufaxian,zheileianjiandouyouyigegongtongdekunjing——neijiushi,guanyuchengyuanshenfenwenti,meiyoufalvyiju。

fayuantongchanghuirenwei,chujianvdequanli,shouxianxuyaoquerentamenshinongcunjitijingjizuzhichengyuan,shichengyuan,cainengxiangshouchengyuandaiyu。danwoguodangshidefalv,bingmeiyou“nongcunjitijingjizuzhichengyuan”derendingbiaozhun。dangranyuanzexingguidingshiyoude,biru《funvquanyibaozhangfa》《nongcuntudichengbaofa》,douyouguanyunannvpingdengqiepingdengxiangyoutudiquanlideguiding,《minfa》lihaiyoupingdenggongpingdeyuanze,zheixiedoukeyiyong。

zhibuguohenduoshihou,fayuanjuede,jiranbiaozhunmeiyouwanquanmingque,neizheiyileianjian,tamenyaomebushouli,yaomeshoulilezaibohui。zuizhongdezouxiang,doushituijicunminzizhi。

wokanhenduozhuanjiaxuezhexiewenzhangdoushuo,zhongguohenda,nongcunhenfuza,guanyuchengyuanzigewenti,bushihezuoxiangxiguiding,yinggaijiaojicunminzizhiqujueding。danzhei20nian,womenjiechulezheimeduojutianli,wojuede,jinguanquanguohenda,nongcunhenfuza,dangenbenwentishiyiyangde——neijiushiduihunjianvxingdeqishihepaichi。danchunyikaocunminzizhidejicengminzhuxingshi,jiushixianshizhongbingbunengyouxiaojiejueqinhaifunvtudiquanyidewenti。

zaiyixiecunli,nongcunjititudiquequandeguiding,henduoshihoujiushicunganbuzijidingde,huozhezhaoyixiecunmindaibiao,kaigehuitaolunyixia:zheibiqianzenmefen?chujianvfenbufen?wangwangzheishihou,dajiadoujuede,chujianvdangranbufen,nifenle,wojiushaole。dajiashicunzailiyichongtude。zheixienvxingwangwangdoubuzhiqing,zhishizuihougongshichulai,caizhidaozijimeiyou。

dangnianzaihubeihonghuyougeanzi,womendelvshiqubangchujianv,cunlijiuqingleyiweifaxuejiaoshoulaidaili,neiweijiaoshouzaifatingshanggongranshuo,zhongguodehunjiazhidujiushicongfuju,“jiachuqudenver,pochuqudeshui”,tahaishuo,jinguanzijishijiaoshou,zainongcunhaiyoutadechengbaodi,ruguozijidejiemeigentazheng,tayebutongyiji。“chujianvjiuyinggaiqupojia,buyinggailiuxialaigenxiongdizhengcaichan。”

weilezheigeanzi,womenqingdonglehubeishengfuliandequanyibuzhang,xiwangfuliannengguanzhu、tuijin。dandangdideyizhitaiqiangdale,womendesuoyougongzuo,zuihoudechengxiaozhibuguoshi——rangzhushenfaguanduiwomenkeqileyidian,bingmeiyouyingxiangpanjuejieguo。zheikanqilaishiyigehenxiaodeguansi,shiminjiande、laobaixingdeliyijiufen,danshijishangshiyizhongquanlizhizheng,beihouqianfuzhefuquanzhidechuantongguannian。

lingwaiyigedianxingdeanzi,shizaineimengbayannaoershidewanfengcun。youyigewaijianvjiaoyangzhijun,1982niancunlifendi,dangshitameijiehun,fendaole2.2mudi,zhihoutajielehun、shenglenver,yijiasankoujiushenghuozaicunli,danshidaole1985nian,cunlituranjiubatahenverdetudishouhuiqule,shuoshigenjuxianlidewenjian,waijianvhezinvdetudiyilvyaoshouhui。hetayoutongyangzaoyude,haiyou68weichujianv。

tadangranjuedehenbugongping,1985nianjiukaishiweiquan,congcunweihui、fulian、xiangzhen、qulidaoshili,jiejuebule,tajiuqisu,yishen、ershen、zaishen,falvchengxuquanbuzouwanle,fayuanrangtazhaozhengfu,zhengfuyaoqiuxiangzhenzhengfuzuzhizhaokaicunmindaibiaodahuilaijueding。huikailehaojici,yizhitongbuguo——jinianqian,tadidihaidanglecunzhang,tamenyijiaguanxihenhao,yehentuanjie,didiyexiangjiejuetadewenti,dancunminbiaojuejiushitongbuguo,buyuanyijitamen。zheigeminzhuchengxushiwufapochude。

yangzhijundexinggehenshaojian,tameiduguoshenmeshu,dandaolitebieqingchu,tashuo,“womenzuoweinvren,bingbushitianshengliduan,yeyinggaibeigongpingduidai”。tahaishuo,“weishenmejiaotamenchujianv,quebujiaonanrenchujiahan?”zheitiaoluzouxialai,womenyoushihoudoumeixinxinle,danshitatebiezhizhe,juebufushu,wulunruhedouyaojianchi,henduoshihou,womenshishoudaotadeguwuhetuidongcaijixuxiaqude。

“zheifenmingshiwozijidequanli,weishenmeyaobierenlaibiaojue?”zheijuhuayangzhijunshuoguo,henduochujianvyeshuoguo。hubeihonghuneigecundechujianv,jiuzhijiewenguocunshuji。qishijiushizheigedaoli。

danzaixianshizhong,nihuikandaocunminzizhizhong,shenzhishizhuanjiaxuezhedejianyizhong,youhenduokansihelidetiaojian,shizeshizaixianzhichujianv,rangtamenshiquan。

biru“yitudizuoweijibenshenghuobaozhang”。henduonvxingbaisu,panjueshulidoushuo,tabuyitudizuoweijibenshenghuobaozhang,zaiwaimianzuoshengyi、dagong……danwentizaiyu,zenmedingyi“baozhang”,xiandairenkoudeyigezhongyaotezhengjiushiliudongxing,nvxingzaiwaimiandagongzhengqian,yanghuoziji,yidanmeinenglile,hainenghuidaotudishang,youkoufanchi,worenweizheijiujiaojibenshenghuobaozhang。tuiyibushuo,nanxingcunminyezaiwaimiandagong,danweishenmefenpeishi,tamendounengfendao?wohoulaiwenguoyiweisixiangbijiaoxianjindefaguan,tashuo,chulehuodeguojiadaiyu(jinrutizhi)deren,qitacunminbenzhishangdoushiyitudiweishengde。wozantongzheizhongshuofa,guojiabatudimianfeijinongmin,jiushiduisuoyounongmindejibenshenghuobaozhang。

zaibiru“zhangqijuzhushenghuozaicunli”。worenshiyiduishandonghezedemunv,weilemanzuzheigeyaoqiu,tamendoubuganlikainongcunqudagong,tamenjuede,wobulikai,doudebudaozheigequanli,neiwolikaile,gengdebudaole。tamenjiuzaidangdizuojiazheng、zuolinggong。dangshiwomenquheze,bangtamenkailejiaoshuifeihedianfeidezhengming,5nianyongle9000duokuaiqiandedianfei,zheikendingnengzhengmingtajiazaizheiershenghuo,danzaifatingshang,cunshujihaishishuo,jucunminfanying,tamenmeiyouzhuzaicunli。nizaiyoushenmezhengju,cunliburen,haihao,zuihoufayuanrenkele。

haiyou“shifoulvxingyiwu”。qishi,renheyizhongshenfenquan,doushixianxiangyouquanli,zailvxingxiangyingdeyiwu,erbushixiangfan。yixiechujianvjiugaosuwomen,cunliweilebimianjitamenquanli,huiburangtamenjinyiwu,birukaihuibutongzhita;jibiantatingshuoyaokaihui,yiqu,renjiajiushuosanhui;bujitaxuanjuquan,tayewufacanyuxuanju。zuihoucunlijiushuo,nimeiyoujinyiwu,suoyiyebunengxiangshouquanli。zongzhi,xianshizhonghuiyougezhongliyoulaixianzhitamen。

keshizheigeshiqingshuodaodi,feichangjiandan——nvxingchushengzaizheili,anzhao《minfadian》deguiding,jiehunhou,nannvshuangfangduijuzhudidouyouxuanzequan,nvxingkeyiliuzainiangjia,yekeyiqupojia,chengweinagejitidechengyuan,doushitadexuanze。henduocunmin,shenzhidifangzhengfuhejicengfayuan,douhuiyouyizhongchengjian,juedetamenliuzaijialishitancai,jiuyinweijiaxiangjingjifazhanshuipinghao。yaorangtamendouliuxialai,fuyucunrenkoubujiubaozhale?

danwomenzhidao,henduochujianvbingbushizheiyang,tamenhenduodoushichengjiaodenvxing,renshilewaidilaidexiaohuozi,jiehunyihou,jiuzaibendishenghuo,shenglehaiziyeliuzaibendi,gongzuoshenghuo、haizishangxuedouhenfangbian。erqietuiyibushuo,jiusuanshiweileliyi,yewukehoufei,sheibuzhuiqiuliyi?basuoyoujihuiheliyidoujinanxingdechuantongguannian,yinggaigaibianle。nikeyifangkaihuaibao,jienaqurudexifuheqitawailaideren,weishenmejiubunengrangnidenverzaizheilianjialuohu?

杨志军(左四)为女儿结婚在村里租的平房。图 / 讲述者提供

选正义,还是选漏洞

zheimeduonian,yaoshuoyoumeiyoupandehenhaodeanzi,dangranshiyoude。

2006nian,neimengguhuhehaoteshizhongyuanpanleyigeanzi——28gechujianv,hukoudouzaicunli,zhangfudoushishangmennvxu,yushangchaiqiananzhi,meijiayinggaifen1.5mutudi、yitao70duopingfangmidezhuzhailou、yitaolinjieshangpu。nixiangzheishiduodadeliyi。

dangshifayuanpantamenyingle,neigepanjueshuxiedehenhao,henzhongshifunvquanyi,shiyongdeshi《funvquanyibaozhangfa》《xiaochuduifunvyiqiexingshiqishigongyue》,haiyinyongle《minfa》deyuanzehejingshen,shibapingdengluozailezhishang。

(zheifenpanjueshuyuanwenzheiyangxiedao:woguoshangweizhidingquedinggaizigedebiaozhun,weijiejuejiufen,yingshiyong《minfatongze》degongpingyuanze、leituipanduandeminfalilun,ji28mingchujianvyuyijingqudejitishouyifenpeidecunminxiangbijiao,ruguoshenfenjiqitatiaojianxiangdeng,zeyeyingdangqudexiangtongdaiyu。benande28mingchujianvchuxingbiewai,qitatiaojianyunanxingxiangdeng,yeyingdangxiangyoutongdengdequanli。)

zheijiushifayuanyinggaiyoudeyizhongzitai:dangyoujutifalvzuoweiyijushi,jiuyijujutidefalv;dangmeiyoujutidefalvyiju,nijiuyinggaigenjufalvdeyuanzehejingshen(laipanan)。

danzhihou,womennazhezheifenpanjueshu,quweiyangzhijundeanjianzhengqushi,yiweifaguanjiushuo,hushizheigeanzijuewujinyou。shenmeyisini?zheigeanjian,qishiyishenyebaisule,baisuhou,28mingchujianvyongshengmingkangzheng,suoyiershencaishengsu。suoyiwoshuo,nvxingdequanlizhenshikangzhengdelaide,yinweizhangqishouyapo,nixiangzhanqilai,zulihenda,zhendeshizaiyongshengmingkangzheng。

suoyishuotongyangdeanzi,weishenmeyoudedifangzhichi,youdedifangbuzhichi,jiushiyinweidangshifalvbuwanshan,youloudong。nixiangzhichichujianv,nengzhaodaoyiju,nibuxiangzhichichujianv,yenengzhaodaoyiju。jiukannizenmexuan,yaobuyaozhuanjianyouloudongdedifangzou。

zheixienian,quanguoyouyixiedifangzuodeyebucuo,zhengzhihuanjinghao,minfengyebucuo,fayuanyebijiaogongping,zheiyangdedifang,chujianvdejiufenxiangduijiushao。

birusichuan,2015nian,sichuanshengnongyetingjiuchutaileyigebiaozhun——nongcunjitijingjizuzhichengyuanquanyijiufen,yihujiweizhuyaobiaozhun,nichushengzaizheigedifang,hukouyezai,jiukeyixiangyouchengyuanquanyi,yinchusheng、jiaqu、shouyang、shenqingjiarudengqingkuang,fuhebiaozhundedoukeyixiangyouquanli。zheigeguidingbijiaoheli,yefuhenongcunshiji,xiangduigongping。zheigeguidingchutaizhihou,womenjiuhenshaojiedaosichuandeqiuzhu。jibianyoujiufen,yinweizhengcemingque,nizhishaokeyiquqisu,erqiefayuantongchanghuizhichi。xiangwomenzhiqianqusichuanguangan,dangdiyouzhengdichaiqian,wojiuwencunmin,“nvxingjiehunhouhukouhailiuzainiangjia,chaiqianfenleyitaofang,dajiahuibuhuiyouyijian?”cunminjiuhuishuo,“neiyoushenme,zhiyaorenjiahukouzaizheili,bierenmeideshuo。”

zaibirushanxixian,2003nian,chengshihuajinchengjiakuai,chuxianlehenduozhengdichaiqianjiufen,chujianvdesuqiujiejuebule,dangshi1000duoweichujianvquweigongfayuan,hentouteng。2004nian,xianshizhongjirenminfayuanjiuchutaileneibuguiding,zhidingleyigerendingchengyuanzigedebiaozhun,zheiyangchujianvdewentijiujiejuele。womenyecongweijiedaoguoxiandetousu。

lingwaihaiyouanhuishenggaoyuan、hainanshenggaoyuan……doushizai2004nian、2008nianzuoyou,zhuanmenzhenduiyongxianchudechujianvdejiufen,chutailezhengce。suoyiyouzhengceyijuhaishibuyiyang,yinweifayuanshizuihouyidaofangxian,youleyiju,fayuanjiukeyipanan。

shenzhiyoushihou,yangzhangdejiushikaimingdeguanyuan。nanninggaoxinquguanweihuiyouyirenzhuren,jiuduichujianvtebietongqing,shangtaizhihou,jiejuelechujianvdewenti。wokanguoyigeshipin,tafabiaojianghua,zhendeshihenganren,nihuijuedeyouzheiyangdeganbu,weilaishiyouxiwangde。dantazhizairenshangsannian,houlaijiudiaodaoxianliqule,zheigezhengceyejiuzhongduanle。

jingguozheixieshiqing,womenhoulaiyeyishidao,jiranhaimeiyouchutaijutidefalv,chujianvdewenti,guangkaosusong,yiyibuda——womenyinggaihuanyizhongfangshi,zhaoyixiediqu,tongguozuoxiangmudefangshi,zixiaershangtuidonglifadewanshan。

yibanlaishuo,womenshiheshengshijifulianhuozhengfuhezuo,zaijicengdefulian、zhengfu、fayuanyijiyoudecunzhuanglaizuoshidian,tuidongdifangzhengfu、fayuanchutaixiangguanwenjian,tuidongshidiancunxiudingcunguiminyue。

hebeixingtaishizhongjirenminfayuan,jiushiwomenzuoguodeyigebijiaochenggongdeshidian。2004nianzhiqian,xingtaizhongyuanneibuyouwenjianguiding,chujianvdeanjiangaibushouli,2007nianwomenyejiedaoguoxingtaichujianvdeqiuzhu。dangshiqicaoneigewenjiandefaguanjiaomaweidong,shiminshifatingdetingzhang。womengangquxingtaizuopeixun,tahendichu,juedejiushibugaishouli,dantayehenshanyuxuexi、shanyutiwen,gezhongguannianjiukaishidajia——houlai,tadeguannianjiumanmangaibianle,juedehaishiyinggaishouli,youyoutaqicaoleyifenxinwenjian,guidingzheileianjianzenmeshouli,shenmeqingkuangxiayinggaibaoliuquanli,xiedehenmingque。2010nian1yue1hao,zheigeguidingchutaile。tadanxinzheigeguidingbuhaozhixing,shenzhihaizhudongshenqingdiaodaozhixingjuzuolejuzhang,henrangrengandong。

邢台中院马维东法官在培训中解析新规定。图 / 讲述者提供

zaiquanguo,xiudingcunguiminyue,zuodezuizao、zuodezuihaodeyinggaishihenandengfengshizhoushancun,shihenandeliangjunlaoshi、zhongyangdangxiaodelihuiyingdengjiweilaoshishengengduoniandejieguo。

womenzuocunguiminyue,qishibuyidingzhijieqierutudiquan,yinweinizhijietitudiquan,henduorenhuijuedemingan,huijujue。henduoshihou,womenshicongyanglaowentilaiqieru。yanglaoshinongcunhenguanzhudewenti,suowei“yangerfanglao”,danshiyangerzhennengfanglaoma?nverjinleyanglaoyiwuma?yingbuyinggaifenjiachan?

liangjunlaoshidetuanduijiuzuoleyigeyanglaohuatimonifatingdeshipin,jiangdejiushiguanyunongcunshanyanglaorenhefenpeijiachandejiufengushi——youyiduilaorenyanglelianggeerzi、yigenver,laorendesuoyoujixudoujilianggeerzimaifangquqi,dengdaolaolebingle,erzimenshigezhongtuituo,nverquexiangfangshefachoushijiansihoufumu,fencaichandeshihou,nverqueyidiandoudebudao,tatebieshangxin。zheiyangdegushizainongcunhenpubian。wenticengcengfenxixialai,dajiajiufaxian,nverjindeshanyangyiwububierzishao,quebufencaichan,queshibugongping。womenmeicizuopeixun,douhuibofangzheigeshipin,henduoxiangzhenganbu、cunganbukanledouhenshouzhenhan,huiliulei。

congcunjitidejiaodulaishuo,yeshiyiyangde。cunjitiduicunlidenverheerzi,shibushipingdeng?ruguobupingdeng,neidajiadouxiangshengerzi。danzheiyangyilai,erziyuelaiyueduo,zuihoudouqubushangxifu,cailiyeyuelaiyuegao。womenjiuconggenyuanshanglaifenxita,yeshixiwanggencunmintaolun,rangdajiakankan,nengbunenggaibianyixieguannian,bapingdengdeguizexiejincunguiminyueliqu。houlaitamendoutongyile。

(2009nianzhoushancunxiudingdecunguiminyue,beichengwei“woguolishishangshoubujuyouxingbiepingdengneirongdecunguiminyue”,congxuduofangmianqingchulecunzhuangqishinvxingde“qianguize”,jutitiaokuanruxia:

chunnvhu、youeryounvhudezinvhunjiaziyou,nandaonvjia、nvdaonanjiajunke,xiangshoubencuncunmindaiyu;

hunchunannvyinlihunhuosangou,jianghukouqianhuibencunzhexiangshoucunmindaiyu;

zhichi、gulifunvcanzhengyizheng,zaihuanjiexuanjuzhong,nvxingdangxuancunmindaibiaobushaoyu50%;ruxuancunliangwei、cunminzuzhangyijiqitacunminyishijigoudebilibudiyusanfenzhiyi;

tichangwenmingjiejiandehunli,fannandaonvjiadehunli,cunliangweidalizhichibingxiezhucaoban;

fuqizaijiatingzhongdiweipingdeng,gongtongchengdanjiawulaodong;

tichangzinvxingshiziyou,suifuxing、suimuxinghuofumushuangxingjunke。)

西宁出嫁女失地后租住的平房。图 / 讲述者提供

代价

xinfameichulaizhiqian,2018nianzuoyou,shiwomenzuijuewangdeshihou——dangshilaiqiuzhudenvxing,youdeyijingzouwanlesusongchengxu,quanbubaisu;youdemeizouwansusongchengxu,yinweifayuanbushouli。youxieanjian,womenhuiquzhaodangdizhengfuxiediaojiejue,youxiezhengfukenengkeqikeqi,jiedaiwomen,yehuishuokaolvzenmejiejue。danwomenyihuilaijiumeixiawenle。

youqishilaoyidainvxingdewenti,jiejueqilaifeichangnan。tamendaduowenhuashuipingbijiaodi,fangfabudedang,biruquweiquanshibudaicailiao,yemeiyouzhengju:cunlizhengleduoshaodi,qizhongyouniduoshaodi,fenpeifanganzenyang?tamentongchangdoubuqingchu。duoshushihouzhishikoutouquzhao,renjiajijuhuajiubatamendafale,meiliuxiarenhewenzihuifu,yincibunengzhengmingtamenyizhizaiweiquan,qisushi,henkenengyiguosusongshixiao。weiquanguochengtaikunnan,daduoshurenmanmanjiufangqile,zhiyoushaoshurenhainengjianchi,youfangfahezhihui,yeyuanyifuchudaijia。

danshinihaishihuikandaozaimanzhangdeshijianzhong,tamenderenshengshizenmemosunde。tamenshiquleqingchun、jiankang,youhenduorenzuihouyelilehun。

woqianmiantidaodeneimenggubayannaoerdeyangzhijun,dangshitahetameimeiyiqiweiquan。juyangzhijunshuo,zhengfudangshifenjitamen7fendekouliangtian,danshicunlirenweilebiaodabuman,tamenzhongshenme,cunmindouqubadiao。zuihoutamentiantianwanshangjiushuizaidilishouzhe,shentishouchaojiashanglaolei,houlaitameimeideleshenbing,40duosuijiuqushile。

yangzhijundangshihuaishanglediergehaizi,yeshiyicihecunmindejiufen,tabeidale,duifangbuzhidaotahuaiyunle。houlaitajiuqubaotai,yongleyao,haizimeiliuchan,haishishengxialaile,danfayudebuhao,liangsuiduojiuqushile。zhendeshifuchuletaidadedaijia。

zhejiangtaizhouyougechujianv,tayoudidi,danhaishixiangzhengquzijidezhaijidi。guoqu20nian,tazaiwaijianvquntilihenhuoyue,shiyigezuzhizhe,renyehennenggan,qishizaizhejiangsuibianzuodianshengyi,dounengshengcunxiaqu,danshitaxuanzeleweiquan。

qianduanshijianwomenlianxita,tagenwoshuo,tahouhuile,shiquleyiqie——lihunle,youmeiyouhaizi,haideleaizheng,shentihenxuruo。taquanjiadoubuzhichita,chuchushoudayahepaichi。xianzaitagukulingdingyigeren,duzizaiwaimianzufangshenghuo。womendangshixiangrangyiweitaizhoujishixishengqukankanta,tayeshifeichanggulv,shuowomenshixishengshinansheng,tapazuolinyoushekandaoyouyixinglai,huishuoxianhua。tajiuzheiyangdanzhanxinjingdiguozherizi。

zaizhejiangdongyang,youyiweigengnianqingdechujianv,tayeshiyouyigedidi,zuikaishi,tadidizaiwaimiandagong,shuozijibuhuihuilaojiale,jialijiudachenggongshi,rangtazhaoxu,liuzaijialishenghuo。danshiguolejinian,didiyoujuedinghuilaile,henkuaijiujielehun,jialijiuburangtazhule,rangtahezhangfunverbanchuqu。taxiangyaoyigezhaijidi,zaicunlijianfangzi,cunliyebuyuanyi。

dangshiwomenqudaotajia,tadejiarenfeichangqiangying。womenxianggentamentantan,tamamahedidijujuejianmian,tababahaodaichuxianle,danwanquantingbujinhua,youyanbujin,yizhishuo,tajiadesuoyoucaichandoushierzihesunzide。zaifumumianqian,tawanquanshishoudayade,shenmehuadoubuganshuo。

dangshitadezhuangtaiyefeichangzhiao,shineizhongzhangqiweiquanshibaizhihoudeyingjizhuangtai。womendanfanyoudianfanduitadeyijian,tajiubugaoxing。dangshitanvercai3sui,henmingxianyebeimamayingxiangle,kanrendeshihou,yeshineizhongdishideyanshen,womenxiangjitayidiantang,tayeshifeichangziwobaohu。

womenshenzhijiejuezheigewentidenandu,xiwangmiaomang,suoyijiuquantashuo,niquzhaogegongzuoba,xianbazijideshenghuogaohao。womenlejieleyixia,zaidangdikaichuzuche,yigeyuedounengzheng9000duokuaiqian,tinghao,shijianyeziyou,danshitashuotabugankaiche。

(2023nian,meirirenwuzuozhecengqudaozhejiang,jiandaolejiweichujianv。dangshiguanchadaotamenjiatingneibudemouxiegongxing:zheixiechujianvdezhangfu,wangwangzaiweiquanzheijianshiqingshangdoushichenmode,tamenbuzuzhiqizizuozheijianshi,danyebuzhichi、bubiaotai、bucanyu。womenyuqizimenliaotianshi,tamenshijialiyigehuisedebeiying。shiquanrucixianxing,dantamenxiwanghulveta,jixushenghuoxiaqu。

dongyangzheiweichujianvshenzhitidao,youduanshijian,tadezhangfubuxiangyaozheigejiatingle,tashi“zijitieshangqu”,jinliweichihetadeguanxi。tayitaishengdeshinver,weileliuzhuzhangfu,tayoushengleertai,shigeerzi。tashuo,erzichushengzhihou,“laogongdexindingxialaile”。)

womenshijuede,duisuoyoudechujianvlaishuodouyiyang——tudiquanyiwenti,bushizhenduimougeren,shiyigexitongxingdewenti。gerendenuli,queshihuituidongshehuijinbu、tuidongfazhijinbu,yinggaiyouzheiyangderenchuxian。danquequeshishi,tadechengbentebieda,fuchutebieduo,nihuidedaoshenmeyangdehuibao,sheidoubuzhidao。

suoyiyinggaixianbazijideshenghuogaohao,buyaoyiyiguxing,zhizuozheiyijianshi。yinweizheiyangdehua,nibazijideyishengdajinqu,xishengdiaojiankanghexingfu,douweibinengzhengdehuilai。dangranle,tamenyouxuanzedeziyou。ruguotamenzheimexuan,womenyidinghuitigonglisuonengjidebangzhu。

与女村官交谈。图 / 讲述者提供

“最好、最适合的法律”

suoyidaole2020nian,womentingshuo《nongcunjitijingjizuzhifa》beilierulifajihua,dangrangandaohengaoxing,juedekandaolexiwang。zhiqianmeiyoutaizhongshita,yemeixiangdaotuijinhuizheimekuai。

jingguozheimeduonian,womenhenmingbai,guanyuchujianvdetudiwenti,zuihaojiushiyouquanguorendatongyilifa,zhidingmingqueqiejutideguiding——yinweiwoguoshichengwenfaguojia,zhiyoufalvguidingle,youmingquedeyiju,zheiyangjiuhenshun,wulunshidifangzhengfuhefayuan,chulijiufendeshihoujiuyouyijukexunle。

guoquqitafalvlifashi,womendouyouguoqidai。zhiqian《nongcuntudichengbaofa》xiuding,womenqidaitanengdui“sheiyouquanlichengbaotudi”zuoguiding。yixieguanzhuxingbiewentidefalvzhuanjiadangshijiutiguo,yaokaolvdaohunjiadenvxing。tamenjiadaopojiazhihou,fenzainiangjiadetudidaibuzou,tudihetongqixiandongzhejiu20、30nian,zheizenmeban?cunjitiyinggaiyaoyuliuyibufentudi,buyaofenwan,baozhanghunjiadefunvyenengfendaodi。dandangshidelifazhejuede,yinggaibaochizhonglidezitai,“fanzhengnannvdouzaiyigejiali,nizainiangjiashi,xiangyouzheigejiadetudi,daolepojia,jiuxiangshoupojiade”,zheijiushixiangdangranle。

houlai《funvquanyibaozhangfa》xiuding,womenyeyouguoqidai,dantayoushidaerquande、changdaoxingdefalv,bukenengjiuyigewentiguidingdehenxi。erqiezaiwoguodesifashijianzhong,zheibufalvhenduoshihoububeishiyong。faguanhuijuede,zhiyoujiatingbaoli、xingsaorao,caishifunvwenti,dannongcuntudiwenti,yijitijingjizuzhiweizhu,bushifunvwenti。

suoyi《nongcunjitijingjizuzhifa》lierulifajihua,womenzhendehengaoxing——tashizuihao、zuishihejiu“chengyuanzige”wentizuochuguidingdefalv,erqieshishouciguiding。ruguoguidingdejuti、xiangxi、kecaozuo,keyimibujishinianlaidequeshi。

erqiefangzihetudi,jiushinongcunzuidadeliyi,zaizheigewentishang,ruguonannvpingdeng,neidajiabuhuizaihushengerhaishishengnv,duiyujiuzhengnanhaipianhao,huifeichangyoubangzhu,cailiwenti、yanglaowentizhubudouhuidedaojiejue。tadeyiyishifeichangdade,danqiantishi,zheitiaofalvyaoguidinghao。

suoyizai2022niandi,《nongcunjitijingjizuzhifa(caoan)》chutai,kaishixiangshehuizhengqiuyijiandeshihou,womenhenkuaijiuduwanlecaoanquanwen,yewenlehenduochujianvdexiangfa,zuihoutichulewomendexiugaiyijian,huyudajiayiqitijiao。

zheifencaoanyouhenrangrenjingxidebufen,youqishidierzhang“chengyuan”bufen,yongjinshigetiaowenguidinglenongcunjitijingjizuzhichengyuandedingyi、queren、quanli、yiwu、tuichu、baoliudengdengredianwenti,shizhenzhengweifalvzhurulelinghun。

danwomenjuede,tayeyouyixiekeshangquezhichu:

birudishiertiao,guanyuchengyuanquedingwenti,shizheimeguidingde,“anzhaozunzhonglishi、jianguxianshi、chengxuguifan、qunzhongrenkedeyuanze,tongchoukaolvhujiguanxi、nongcuntudichengbaoguanxi、shengchanshenghuoqingkuang、jibenshenghuobaozhanglaiyuan、duijitijileidegongxiandengyinsu”。

womendangshiyikan,suowei“zunzhonglishi”“qunzhongrenke”dengdeng,jialezheimeduoxiandingtiaojian,shibushishuo,yiqiancunminmenrendingmougechujianvbuxiangshouquanli,neiyihouyeyinggaizunzhongzheigejuece?xianshizhong,wanquankeyiyongzheixietiaokuanlaizuankongzi。womendangshijiuzheigetiaokuantilexiugaiyijian。

zaibirucaoandishijiutiao“busangshichengyuanshenfendeqingxing”,taguiding“funvchengyuanbuyinsangou、lihunersangshijitijingjizuzhichengyuanshenfen”。danshijishang,henduonongcundiqu,dalingweihun、jiehun、zaihundenvxing,yehuibeipaichuzaijitizhiwai。suoyiwomenjiujianyi,bazheitiaogaicheng“funvchengyuanbuyinweihun、jiehun、sangou、lihun、zaihundengersangshijitijingjizuzhichengyuanshenfen”。

shuoshihua,henduoshihou,womentizheixiejianyi,qishiyebuquedingnengbunengbeicaina。danwomenyiranyaoti,yaoxiechulai,baliyouxiedehenchongfen,yinweizheiyeshiyizhongxuanchuanhejiaoyu。

zhenzhengdao2024nian6yue,《nongcunjitijingjizuzhifa》gongbu,womenfaxianlifazhehaishicainalehenduojianyi,duichengyuanzigedeguiding,yigongyoujiutiao,bijiaomingque,biwomenxiangxiangzhongyaohaohenduo。

qizhongmingquetidao,nongcunjitijingjizuzhichengyuan,“buyinwugong、jingshang、lihun、sangoudengyuanyinsangshishenfen”——womenjianguohenduoanli,nvxingjiushiyinweizheixieyuanyin,beiboduolequanyi;haiyouyitiaoguiding,shuojitijingjizuzhidechengyuan,ruguojiehunle,danmeiyouzaiqitadifangqudechengyuanshenfen,neimeyuancunjiti,yebunengquxiaotadeshenfen,zheitiaoyeshiduihunjianvxingyoulide。

erqiedinggaohaizhuanmentidaolefunvquanyi,“funvxiangyouyunanzipingdengdequanli”,zheixiangdangyushiba《funvquanyibaozhangfa》lideneirongyiguolaile,zheihenrangrenxinwei,shihenyoubiyao、yehenhaodeyidian。

xinfagongbuneitian,henduochujianvdouhenxingfen,youqishiguangxi、guangdong、shandongdenvxing,tamenzijidedaiyukenengjiejuele,danzinvyizhidoushibeipaichide。erxinfamingqueguidingle,“duiyinchengyuanshengyuerzengjiaderenyuan……yingdangquerenweinongcunjitijingjizuzhichengyuan”。henduorengenwoshuo,neitiantamenhenwandoumeishuizhe。

在江苏省试点村修订村规民约讨论会的现场。图 / 讲述者提供

隐忧与期待

xinfa2025nian5yue1haoshengxiao,dancongjinnianxiatiantagongbukaishi,youxiedifang,yijingyoulesongdong。

zaineimenggutongliao,jiuyouyigeanzi,shejidaocunlidetudibuchangkuan,meiniancunlidoufa,zuijinzheici,meiweicunmindounengfayiwanyuan,dantamenzhifenjichujianv500yuan。quancunyou75weichujianv,tamendangranbutongyi,houlaijianchajiguanjieru,qugencunjitixiediaogoutong,diaojiezhihoudejieguoshi——zheicideyiwanyuan,chujianvdounengxiangyou,nanxingcunminnaduoshao,tamenjiunaduoshao。

danyinweifalvmingniancaishengxiao,shuyutamendezhei75wanyuan,cunjitiyijingfangzaileyigezhuanmendezhanghushang,dengmingnian5yue1ri,《nongcunjitijingjizuzhifa》yishengxiao,zheiqianjiujitamen。

xianzaiwomenduixinfazuidadedanyou,jiuzaiyudishiertiaodiyikuan:“nongcunjitijingjizuzhitongguochengyuandahui,yijuqiantiaoguidingquerennongcunjitijingjizuzhichengyuan”,yisihaishishuo,chengyuanzigehaishiyoucunminzizhi,jikaicunmindahui,shaoshufucongduoshulaijueding。womenduixianshibijiaolejie,danxinzheitiaofalv,huichengweichujianvzhengququanlishizuidadezuai。

jugelizi,jinnianwomenquleyitangshandong,dangdiyougeanli,shigeshuangnvhujiating,fuqinyinweizhongnanqingnv,henzaojiuheqizilihunle,qulewaidi,zuchenglexinjiating,zheiweimuqinjiudaizhelianggenverzaicunlijixushenghuo,danverhaizaicunlizhaolexu。houlaizheiweifuqindaizheerhundeqizi、erzihuilaile,cunlijiugendanvershuo,niyoudidile,neinijiushichujianv,buxiangshoucunmindaiyule,boduoletadequanyi。zhiqiantameiniannengfendaozhengdihezudikuan,houlaijiumeiyoule。

zheigenverbufu,quqisu,fayuanpantashengsule,danshishuyutadeqian,yizhiwufaluoshi。womenjiuqudangdi,xiangkankandaodizenmehuishi,daolezhihoufaxian,yinweitaqisule,cunminduitajiayijianhenda。kaicunmindahui,dajiadoubutongyibaqianjita;tadagongzanqianmaideyiliangche,beirenzale;gebiyiweinanxingcunminheledianjiu,jiumatamama,shuotalaizaicunlibuzou,fendajiadecaichan,haibatamamadale;tamamayebeicunganbutichulecunlideweixinqun,taxiangwendianshenmeshi,cunlirendoubulita。jiushizheiyangyizhongfenwei,tamenyijiashihenshougulide。

youyitianwanshang,womenzaicunliliuda,heyixiecunminliaotian。buguanshinanxingcunminhaishinvxingcunmin,tamendoushishuo,“zaiwomennongcun,falvpanyingle,yemeiyong,womendoushianzhaotubanfalai。(suoyouquanyi)chujianvdoushibunengyoude。yaoshidoujifen,neisuoyounvhaijiehunhoudoubuzoule。”

jingliguoleisideshiqing,womenjiuhuijuede,ruguohaishiyouchengyuandahuilaiquerenchengyuanshenfen,huiyouqianzaidefengxian——yudaobujianglidecunjiti,jinjin“cunminzizhi”zheiyitiao,jiukeyituifansuoyoujinbu。womendangranxiwangsuoyoucunmindouyuanyigaibian,danfalvbunengjixiwangyurendedaode。youqishidangliyihendadeshihou。

suoyiwomenxianghuyudeshi,mingnian5yue《nongcunjitijingjizuzhifa》shixinghou,nengchutaigengxizhideshishibanfa,huozhenengzhenduiyouxietiaokuan,zuogengxizhidesifajieshi。womendangranzunzhongcunminzizhi,danruguo,cunminzizhizuochulebugongzhengdejueding,fayuankeyitongguopanjuezuohefaxingshencha,zhengfukeyitongguoxingzhengjuedingshuyifajiucuo,erbushizaituihuijicunminzizhi。

rangneixiexiangzunshoufalvderen,youfakeyi。rangneixiebuzunshoufalvderen,dedaochengfa。yerangneixieshiquanderen,dedaojiuji。

dangran,falvyongyuanshidixian,genggenbendehaishizaijiaqiangnongcundiqudexuanchuan,rangdajiashulixingbiepingdengdeguannian。zhiyouguannianzhuanbianle,falvcaihuiyoutadeturang。

qishizheijianshikeyihenjiandan。woxiangjiangyige20nianqiandegushi。dangshijiaoyubuyougeguiding,daxueshengbenkejieduanbunengjiehun,yanjiushengheboshijieduanbunengshenghaizi。2004nian7yuedeyitian,wojiedaileyiweinvboshi。

dangshita30sui,hezhangfudouzaibeijingyisuoxuexiaodubo,yeshiyiwaihuaiyunle,tadeshentibudahao,yishengjianyitabahaizishengxialai。qishitayijingjiehunle,youshidiyitai,wanquanfuhe《hunyinfa》he《jihuashengyufa》,dandangshijiushiyinweijiaoyubudeguiding,xuexiaojiubatakaichule。danshitazhangfumeishi,haizaijixudubo。

dangshiwomenyougeguwen,zhongguorenmindaxuedeyangdawenjiaoshou,shizhongguohunyinfaxuededianjirenzhiyi,tabianzhulezhongguodiyibuhunyinjiatingfajiaocai,yeshi1980nian《hunyinfa》he1992nian《funvquanyibaozhangfa》deqicaozuchengyuan,tadangshitebiezhichizheigenvshengquqisu。dantakaolvdaozhangfuhaizaidushu,bugan,fangqile。

womenjiuzhenduizheiqianjian,zhaokaileyigeyantaohui,qinglemeiti、zhuanjiaxuezhe、gaoxiaoguanlizhelaikaihui,dangshijiaoyubudeguanyuanyelaile。tazaixianchangshuo,shinianqian,tamenjiuxiangquxiaozheigeguiding,danyouhaipaquxiaozhihou,xuexiaochengleyuyingtang。nvhaizishangdaxuejiujiehun,yanjiushengjiushenghaizi,jiaoyujihuadouyaobeidaluan,haoxiangyidanzhengcefangkai,jiuhuichuhendaluanziside。

huihou,meitiduizheigehuiyizuolebaodao,yigeyuehou,jiaoyubujiubazheigeguidingquxiaole(2005nian3yueguojiajiaoyubugongbuxinban《putonggaoxiaoxueshengguanliguiding》,quxiaoledaxueshengjiehunxujingxuexiaotongyidejiuguiding)。zheimeduonianguoqule,shishizhengming,daxuebingmeiyouchengweiyuyingtang。rendoushilixingde,nvhaizibuhuiyinweizheigeguidingbucunzaile,jiusuisuibianbianjizheshenghaizi。

tongyangdedaoli,nongcundenvhaizi,bingbuhuiyinweiyoulequanyi,jiuquandouliuzaicunlibuzou。tamenyaojincheng、dushu、zhaogongzuo,renshilixingde、liudongde。danzuizhongyaode,shiwomenyinggaijitamenxuanzedeziyouhequanli。

本文为转载内容,授权事宜请联系原著作权人。