记者丨闫桂花
duanduanshurikuaisutongguo,erqiehaishiyidaoqiede“yijinlezhi”——aodaliyazhengfu11yueditongguoyixiangfalv,jinzhi16suiyixiaqingshaonianshiyongshejiaomeiti。shuodao“yijinlezhi”,wangwanghuilianxiangqiguanliaozhuyideduoxing、taobizerendeqingxiang、duikexueguilvdemoshi,yijikenengdailaidefanxiaoguodengdeng,danweishenme,dangwomentandaojinyanjindu,jiubuhuiyouzheimeduodefumianlianxiangchansheng,fanerhuijiangqishiweiliguolimindebiyaojucuo?
wentijiuzaiyuweihaidechengdu——shifeichangyanzhong、keburonghuan,haishikeyixuxutuzhi?yiji,butongjianguanmoshi(rubujianguanhuozheqingjianguan)dejieguo——shifoukeyidachengmubiao,haishihuidailaiyiliaozhiwaidehouguo?
congzheilianggejiaodulaizhankaifenxi,keyihuidayanxiazhongguolaishuoyigefeichangzhongyaodewenti——womenshifouyingdangxiaofangaodaliya,duiqingshaoniandeshejiaomeitishiyongjinxingqiangjianguan?daanshikendingde。
aodaliyazhengfude《2024wangluoanquanxiuzhengan》congtijiaodaocanyiyuanhezhongyiyuanxiangjitongguo,zhenggelifaguochengyongshijinyizhou,kanchengshensu;danshijishangzaicizhiqianduonian,aodaliya,yijimeiguo、faguodengduoguojiuyijingjiucijinxingguodaliangyanjiuhezixun、shenyi,bingduishejiaomeitideweihaijibendachenglegongshi。gaiantongguoqian,aodaliyayixiangdiaoyanxianshi,77%derenzhichizheiyijinling。
duoxiangyanjiubiaoming,shejiaomeitiyinfadepanbihebuqieshijideqiwang,huidaozhiyiyuhejiaolv,duiweichengnianren,youqishinvxing,houguoyouweiyanzhong;shejiaomeitidejiangshangjizhiyehuiyoufayonghuchengyin,daozhiduobaanguoshancheyiyangjizenghexiaohao,dailaidizizun、kongxu、gudu,xianshishenghuodehuobanjiaowangjianshaodengdeng;gengzhongyaodeshi,shejiaomeitihepingmunimingxingzhuzhanglewangluoqiling,daozhishehuipaichi、yaoyanchuanboherenshengongji,yixiehaiziyinciersangming。
womenshenghuozaiyigequanqiuqingshaonianxinlizhuangkuangkanyoudeshidai。meiguoshehuixinlixuejiaqiaonasen·haite(jonathan haidt)zhuyidaolezheiyiwenti,yujinnianchuntianchubanleyibenmingwei《jiaolvdeyidai》(the anxious generation)deshu,haochengyao“weiyongshiyongdaiderenleiduohuirenleishengming”。weicitacong2019nian2yuekaishifabuyifen,muqianyishoujilaiziduogeguojiahediqude384xiangxiangguanyanjiu。congzheixieyanjiuzhong,tafaxian,2010nianshiqingshaonianyiyu、jiaolvkaishijizengdeguanjianjiedian,qizhongzaimeiguo,jiezhi2020niandeyixiangdiaoyanxianshi,12-17suideqingshaonianguoquzhishaojingliguoyicizhongduyiyufazuo(major depressive episode)debili,nvxingzaiguoqushinianzengjiale145%,nanhaizhengtishuipinggengdi,danzengsugengkuai,dadao161%。lingyixiangyanjiuzexianshi,meiguo10-14suiertongzishabili、yinzicanbeishouzhijizhenshidebili,yezai2010nianhoukuaisushangzhang,jiezhi2020nian,zishabilinvhaishangzhangle167%,nanhaizengjiale91%;zicanbili,nvhaizengfushi188%,nanhaizengfu48%。leisideqingkuangyechuxianzaiaodaliya、jianadayijibeiouguojia。
zheigeguanjiande2010nian,yushejiaomeitikaishiliuxingdeshijianzhenghaowenhe。2000niandai,gaosukuandaikuaisupuji;2007nian,iphoneshoujimianshi,dailailechaobingdushishejiaomeitixinshidai;2009nian,dianzan、zhuanfahefenxianganniuchuxianbingzhujianchengweishejiaomeitidehexingongneng,conggenbenshanggaibianlewangluoshijiedeshejiaodongtai,jiangshejiaomeiticongdanchundeshejiaogongjuzhuanbianweiyizhongfankuiqudongdexitong,jishihehuixiangfankuijizhi(feedback and reinforcement loops)xueruolezhenshihudongdeyiyi,tongshisuanfaqudongdetuijianjizhifangdalefumianqingxu,rufennu、kongjuhechouhen。
dangran,xiangguanbingbudengyuyinguo。haiteyeyishidaolezheigewenti。duici,takaochaleqitakenengdeyuanyin,rujingjizhuangkuang、yishixingtaidebianhua,qihouweijidengdeng,danfaxian,wulunnagehuonayixiezuhedouhennanduiqingshaoniandexinlizhuangkuangchanshengrucizhongdadeyingxiang。zai《jiaolvdeyidai》li,taxiedao,1980niandaiyiqian,tongnianshiyoulechanglidemaoxianheyouyi,shidaziranlidebenpaohetansuo,danzaishejiaomeitishidai,tamendetianxingbeiyibubumomie,bianchengleduozaibeiwolidingzhepingmudeyidai。
shishishang,shenjingxuejia、xinlixuejiayezaoyicongshenglicengmian,jinggaogenshejiaomeitixiangguandesuanfahehuixiangfankuiduirenyouqishiweichengnianrendanaodesunshang。beixuanweiniujindaxuechubanshe2024nianduciyude“naofu”(brainrot)yici,yijingxingxiangzhanshilehulianwangyidaizaisuosui、huangdan、haowuyiyidewangluoxunishijiechenmi,yuzhenshishijiegeli,gudu、zhuyilihuansanyijixinzhiruohuadezhuangtai——xiangbimeigerendouduoshaotiyanguozhongyucongpingmushangnakaiyanjinghouneizhongturanerzhidekongxu、mangrande“jieduan”fanying。
duidanaorengweifayuwanquandeqingshaonianlaishuo,zheizhongweihaiyoushen。mali·k. siwengeer(mari k. swingle)shimeiguozhumingdelinchuangxinliyishiheshenjingzhiliaoshi,jiyu20niandelinchuangheyanjiujingyan,tazai《jiechi:shouji、diannao、youxiheshejiaomeitiruhegaibianwomendedanao、xingweiyujinhua》yishuzhongtidaolechenmiwangluokenengjidanaodailaidezhenqiedebianhua:yingxiangqingshaoniandanaodekuangehui、fugehe、wenzhuangtidengjiangshangxiangguannaoqudezhengchanggongneng,duixiangyingdejiangshangxinxichulicunzaiyichang,daozhiqianeyeyuhaimatihexieqianyedegongnenglianjiejianruo,daozhirenzhigongnengshousun,yijijianshaoqingshaoniandekoudaihuihuizhimidudengdeng。
dangran,bingbushisuoyouzhuanjiadourenkehaitedepanduan。youxuezhezhuanmenzhenduihaitetidaode300duoxiangyanjiuyiyixiangcha,renweiqizhonghenduocunzaishujuwentihuozhetongjifangshicuowu。duici,aodaliyayixiangzhengfuwenjianyetidao,guanyushejiaomeitideyingxiangkenenghuiyouguobiechayi,jixuchengshudekuaguoshujudegongxiang。
yeyourenfanbo,shejiaomeitihuoxujihaizimendailailehuoduohuoshaodeshanghai,dantongshi,tayefahuilehenduojijidezuoyong,biru,weinianqingrenyouqishibianyuanrenquntigongyigezhichixingshequdeng。
zheijiuyinchulediergewenti:butongdejianguanmoshifenbiehuidailaishenmeyangdejieguo?nazhongzuofazuizhongshouyizuida?
aodaliyazhengfuzaitongguo《2024wangluoanquanxiuzhengan》zhiqian,cengjingjisuanguoshouyihechengbendequanheng。tamenduixiangguanliyifang(qingshaonian、jiazhang、shejiaomeitigongsi)deyingxiangjinxinglezonghepinggu,dechuleduimeigezhengcexuanxiangdejingxiaoyipingfen,faxian,ruoweichixianzhuang,jingxiaoyijiangwei-5,qingshaonianhejiazhangshouhaijiaoda;ruosheding16suizuidinianlingxianzhi,jingxiaoyiweiling,qingshaonianhejiazhangjiangshoudaodezhengmianxiaoyingyushejiaomeitigongsiheyonghudedaodefumianxiaoyingzhenghaodixiao。
qiangliefandui16suiyixiaweichengnianrenshiyongshejiaomeitibingzaibuyiyulituidongguohuilifadehaite,weiraoyouguantadezhiyi,rucifanbodao:juecezheyinggaikaolvpasikadeduzhu(pascal’s wager)——tingcongjinggaojishicuowu,sunshixiaoqiekeni;hushijinggaoruocuowu,daijiajudaqienanyinizhuan。huanjuhuashuo,yexushejiaomeitideweihaibingmeiyoufeichangda,danzaikenengdejudadefengxianmianqian,caiquxingdong,yongyuanyaobizuoshibuligenghao。
zai《jiaolvdeyidai》kaipianzhong,haitedalegejingmiaodebiyu:jiashenidehaizibeixuanding,jiarudiyigeyongjiuxingdehuoxingrenleidingjudian,haizixihuantaikong,jiashangtasuoyoudepengyoudoubaomingle,suoyizaiwuxunitongyideqingkuangxiayecanjialezheigerenwu。zheigedingjudianxuyaohaizimen,yinweitamenbichengrengengnengshiyinghuoxingshangdeteshutiaojian,youqishidizhonglihuanjing。ruguohaizimenzaihuoxingshangjingliqingchunqiheshengzhangtuzeng,tamendeshentijiangyongjiushiyinghuoxingdehuanjing,tamenyeyongyuanbuhuifanhuidiqiu。nihuiyuanyima?dangranbuhui,yinweinihuikaolvhuoxingshangdefushe、dizhonglidengduihaizishentihexinlideqianzaiweihai。shejiaomeitijiuleisihuoxing,tongyangquefabaohucuoshi、tongyangxuyaofuchushiyinghuanjingdedaijia,yijitongyangmianlinjiazhangnanyijianguandejingdi,weishenmewomenjiuyinggaifangrenhaizimenzaizheigexunide“huoxing”shangmanyou?
xiangbixifangguojia,zhongguoduiqingshaonianhulianwangdeguanliyinggaisuanshibijiaozaoyexiangduiyange,biruguidingwangluopingtaiqiyebunengweibuman16suiweichengnianrentigongwangluozhibofuwu;pingtaixuyaotigongweichengnianrenmoshi,fenlingtuijianneirong、yinzangweichengnianrendiliweizhi;weijingxuexiaoyunxu,weichengnianxueshengbudejiangshoujidengzhinengzhongduanchanpindairuketang;yiji,“suoyouwangluoyouxiqiyejinkezaizhouwu、zhouliu、zhourihefadingjiejiarimeiri20shizhi21shixiangweichengnianrentigong1xiaoshiwangluoyouxifuwu,qitashijianjunbudeyirenhexingshixiangweichengnianrentigongwangluoyouxifuwu”dengdeng。
zheibeizuoweizhichengzhongguowuxucaiqugengduojianguanxingdongdelunjuzhiyi。ranershishishi,muqiandejianguanyuanyuanbugou。biru,《xianyuweichengnianrenwangluoxiaofeidiaoyanbaogao》wenjuandiaoyanxianshi,shiyongguoqingshaonianmoshideweichengnianrenzhanbihaibudaoyiban,gengzhongyaodeshi,ruguonidakaiqingshaonianmoshi,huifaxianlimiandeneirongbujindandiao、fawei,youxieshenzhixiandedizhi,qiezongtishuliangyouxian。
zhongguoxuyaocaiquxingdonghaiyoulianggegengzhongyaodeyuanyin,yishizhongguoweichengnianrenshangwangbiliquanqiujushou,qiezhongguowangluoyingyongchangjingduo,yeweiqingshaonianshiyonggezhongshejiaomeititigonglejihui;ershizaizhongguochengxiangfazhanshiheng、cunzaidaliangliudongertongdedabeijingxia,shoujiheyouxiyijingchenglehenduoxiangduiluohoudexianxiangdiqudehaizimendediyipeihuzhe。
shide,henduowangluowentidegenyuanzaiyushehui——zhenggeshehuidouzaijiasu,womenyeduiziji、duihaizishijialeyuelaiyuegaodeqiwang,wulunshigongzuohaishixueye,neijuanyichengweichangtai,yuelaiyueyuanzihuadejiatingjiegouxia,haizimendeshenghuoriqubeiguhuayuxuexiaohejiating,quefafengfudekewaishenghuohepeibandengdeng。zheixiedoushishenke、zhangyuandeshehuiwenti,duanshijiankongpahennandedaojiejue。
qiayinruci,jianguandebiyaoxinggengjiatuxian。dangfumuyaomebeikunzai“996“degongzuorichang,yaomexianyujingxiyuer、muzhichengfa,wanquanrangjiazhanglaichengdanpingmujianguandezerenjibuxianshi、yebuyouhao。
haiyouguandianrenwei,weichengnianrenyeyoucanyushuzifazhandequanli,chengnianrenwuquanboduo。zhengrubeijingqingshaonianfalvyuanzhuyuyanjiuzhongxinzhurentonglihuazaicaixinshangkanwensuoyan,“chengnianrenwangwangxiangdangrandirenwei,weilehaizidefuzhi,keyijuedingshenzhizhuzaihaizideyiqie。qishizaizheigeguochengzhong,chengnianrenshehuifuchudedaijiawangwangjiushieshalehaizidelingxingyijichuangzaoli,erlingxingyijichuangzaolizairengongzhinengshidaiqiaqiashirenleishehuizuibaoguide,shirenyuzhinengrenzuibenzhidequbie。” danshuzifazhan,buyidingfeiyaoyilaishejiaopingtai,zhishaobushixianxingzheizhongyishandongqingxu,yiliuliangyinglidemoshixiadeshejiaopingtai。shijishang,zaiaodaliyadezhengcezhongjiupaichuleyoutube、messenger kids、whatsapp、ertongbangzhurexianhegugeketangdengjiankanghejiaoyufuwu。
genghekuang,shuzimeijie,zhendekeyicujinhaizidechuangzaolima?mali·k. siwengeerdeguanchazhidewomenshensi。tazai《jiechi》yishulitidao,guodushiyongshuzimeijiehuixianzhujiangdiαnaobodehuoyuedu,dangzheixienaobohuodongjianshaoshi,kenenghuiduidanaodechuangzaoxingsiweihezhuanzhulizaochengfumianyingxiang。
当然,一刀切的禁止措施,到底能起到多大作用还很难说。澳大利亚政府给了平台一年时间,让它们开发技术,阻止16岁以下未成年人开设账号。在这个过程中还会有无数的问题涌现出来,如何确保隐私,如何验证年龄信息,如何收集,谁来收集等等。但至少,这一法案释放出了一个强有力的信号,即不会任由未成年人在毫无安全保证的情况下在火星上漫游。当这个信号发出,至少可以引发更全面、深入的讨论,至少可以争取到一个相对安全的期限,让平台打好“安全补丁”,让成年人尽可能地修补好让无数未成年人陷入抑郁、焦虑的破碎的角落,比如打造适合青少年活动的场域,培养孩子的数字素养,为需要关爱的留守儿童和进城务工儿童,以及遭受家庭暴力或者校园欺凌的孩子,提供适当的服务和法律保障,等等。就像全球的禁烟共识也经历了漫长的波折、克服了大量经济利益和社会观念的阻力方得以达成,数字时代的青少年保护buhuiyicuerjiu,danzhishao,aodaliyabanbendeshejiaomeitijinlingjiangshiyicijijidechangshihetupo。
评论